Cubase Direct Offline Processing audio dropouts on FX plugins

[d.healey]

@tomekslesicki What else does your plugin do besides convolution?

[DanH]

@d-healey Would be good to know all the things IPP is used for - I've got it down as Convolution Reverb and the Audio Analysers

[tomekslesicki]

It’s convolution, a filter, curve EQ (with no visuals) and simple gain. That’s pretty much it.

[d.healey]

@tomekslesicki Have you tested disabling the convolution, leaving everything else enabled, and seeing if you get the same result?

[tomekslesicki]

@d-healey I’ll give it a shot!

[tomekslesicki]

@d-healey I can confirm that it’s only the convolution that’s causing this.

[tomekslesicki]

The problem is still there with IPP and Multithread but here’s some interesting new info:

The plugin has a dry / wet knob, which balances to signal router chains - one dry, obviously, and the other one... ;-)

So, with signal all wet, the problem is there.

With signal all dry, no issue, but also no convolution.

But the funny thing is, if I'll wiggle the dry / wet slider before rendering with the Direct Offline Processing, the problem is gone.

It appears again once the impulse is changed, but wiggling the dry / wet again solves it once more.

[Dan Korneff]

@tomekslesicki said in Cubase Direct Offline Processing audio dropouts on FX plugins:

but wiggling the dry / wet again solves it once more.

Interesting find

[tomekslesicki]

This post is deleted!

[tomekslesicki]

Ok, another interesting find: it’s not about actually changing the value of the HISE modules (dry / wet on the Convolution or gain on Simple Gain modules), it’s about Cubase needing the slider assigned to them moved on the interface for the Direct Offline Processing to work...

I’ll program a value change to the dry / wet slider as the impulse is changed and see what will happen, but since the impulses are mapped to a slider that can be adjusted rather quickly, it’s hard for me to implement a walkaround to this issue which would actually remember the dry / wet slider’s value in a reliable way. Not sure if it’s even worth the trouble as I don’t know what’s causing this issue in the HISE backend.

@d-healey @Christoph-Hart I’d really appreciate your support on this.

[tomekslesicki]

Another update: programming a change to the slider doesn’t work. It needs to be moved on the interface for direct offline processing to work.

[tomekslesicki]

...yet still: no convolution, no problem. Strange?

[tomekslesicki]

A friendly bump :-)

[d.healey]

Have you made a bug report - https://forum.hise.audio/topic/4260/the-definitive-feature-request-bug-fix-roadmap ?

[tomekslesicki]

Yup, just under your first post there. It’s 4th or 5th reply I think.

[tomekslesicki]

@Christoph-Hart could you please fix this? :-)

[tomekslesicki]

Hey @Christoph-Hart was this by any chance fixed in one of the recent commits?

[Lindon]

@tomekslesicki said in Cubase Direct Offline Processing audio dropouts on FX plugins:

Hey @Christoph-Hart was this by any chance fixed in one of the recent commits?

look in the bug list post - you will see when it is fixed... its not currently fixed.

[Christoph Hart]

@tomekslesicki Unfortunately, no. I'm planning a rather big redesign of the convolution algorithm, but it's a little bit down the roadmap (JUCE 6 now has a FFT wrapper for the IPP so maybe I will replace my own wrapper with this one).

However I have made a few changes to the convolution reverb a few weeks ago which I think are not part of the master branch, so if you feel lucky you might try to compile your plugin with the develop branch and see if this is fixed.

[tomekslesicki]

@Christoph-Hart any updates, please? It’s a serious issue and it appears in PT too as suggested earlier.