MIDI out?

[ulrik]

@Lindon the only way I have been able to get midi out is from a Hise compiled MidiFX Plugin inside Logic

[lalalandsynth]

@ulrik Will a midifx plugin output CC as well ?
Is the midiFX plugin "format" only for Logic ?

Really need to be able to get midi/cc output from a plugin.

[ulrik]

@lalalandsynth I don't know about cc output but I guess it will work, however the Hise MidiFXPlugin is only working in Logic I guess, I tried in Ableton Live 13 but no luck.

In this plugin I'm using an arpeggiator which will trigger on incoming midi and output the midi from the arp

I am investigating different scenarios and I will tell you if I try the midi CC stuff

video

To be able to build a MidiFXPlugin I had to enable it in the projucer project

This snippet should work when compiled, if Hise is compiled with "HISE_MIDIFX_PLUGIN" enabled

HiseSnippet 1764.3ocyYstbSaDEVNIKkXZn.kY5e0jo+HLC00NIDRmNsX6XmDUbbzDYRCkoCHKsxdajWYjWYH81viReT3+8knOB7FzdN5h85qQwElA+Corma624n8bN6tQ22yh1qmmuRlUabQWpRlOkXbAWzdu1lLthVEkL2fbDyls+Yk76pT9htl85QsUxjY4CPAxr5JJg+d2iJa5ZxsnCIonbpGyhVi0gIFRUu3iYtt6aZSav5HI81E0r736445E.fYYRdktlVma1hV2DEaIhRlqU0lI77MDlBZOkLqT1y9Bi1duhGI+ordrltTbPAECvPQj22y0FQLRUYu1LWa8DmtmBXE8ggfkiBA2MziGPeXn3VgLTGpgb7HyRiBukGAdEjgWdI3MEHszjPZMBD9osZwLgYHDK2TlRgQQxxoFIElKRT1yiKnbAfoOG+SeOWPTQHhtIwvxm0UTNPH73JLajTDJhI02zMXjkCJovFqQNg1iJtxlvvkYS8CMwmQpGzwPP6FSaLijuXZLxMHnEBwxhghaEZ.iyYy.Fu6QoIb.VwyW7X5E89+DQ.moKkZ+XtWywMvcmLZbqXCrmWmldk8dcnItCwf9x.JjfOfb5cHInrF4XKgYe5Il7VzEyaVkXzNvwwktXqvtAoJ2DV92fQmmKrRjAtyHyuNTRJzH2EBGcXM73TIFiYsbEsMElJYdFYmsyA+pUpTtb8qTA9SCc3wg33bkwwU5CO1J2dvyp0fG+HNtYIXrSkZI70ygxWBkeqfP4Kojd7dJ00yhItH83UuLLe+zO.y2guDwq.G2GG2+b8P7g34aPPO7mSUfuCx2YKT9tOFwaOT9JkSOduCoFk2RzN0n0ggy1CODmsV3r0GQ2gG.i06fnoEx+LjeeGjecbriFxuMN9An7UP9mE5ssGAsyK031DnCAmScMntTKr97kmYLUC8EjiCDcCDumL2sIGoWE5A3mXvIxWRYt+mgFpJ2dFlYNETkR6tF4PnQ7TRYkZ1sRTytaGq8PNQ6CQCZF46XB6wPtaWjrJK82KQhaWkqi44z88gACzXicxm+9pvi68sYyB6ynmPsuoupbKT0uSMbmO4ZQEiz+ei0kEacvBiXfvRq0Z5B5mL+fEf.XWn5.WDpchLnxYy5Saox6Cx+r0K70EV+9pvqMqD+N9Uin2aGSd63Wwj2Ml7twu.xYQasSL8B6j7NVgsRr+Val7NlyNISwNam7tw5+LBSF2kwopNAbKAyiq5wS7j3O2aXk3j2WM7658x9aYWUNXkCZeVRH7YMCDzMFgyfNRI59sgplDoPM2XcA80B.U79OKTleFD5O.nM+3752CUNFi6Y551DJerwDnGrkjqU2SPOluQnGj8OxpNNKGmoxK1VtT+oxF2hq+7TbCdPmlTe43GJHjJL5V3HoaKbVQAFIA83Zbl33tT9r1Arzl7tVpxiO5IMpNuVuyux90HkNQuvGy8JCQ3leL2cLDga8QQGwor+rqimLA1B9hsw6rjj7zorU0mnUAcQnre7hVXgbWpufg4HYpP6Cm2LpGxpjJzdmK75BmncPMB.aW155WOb99xhWHO3ULaQ6gDZTrMk0pszIa+9hcSRqzrm3.ZcM8gCxBsizl7jRJShv0hQXMylPG2nSWIQofLPYx.UabfxlBPw5pgGp7D8pGbfVoFGehhCDQMX+53evth.aSIfU7EyKBVLXl.CNmsVEM08OSUu1SNPq9khsOIMkbjhX0k.VweY7H1eNAvd5b+zNknz7KsLCj7OA+eQxvoSiaSecRI+qD71ZVv6u9yO.vayQf2ZWdQkY.t2b53KudwDfSK8InieGBIIL0exQpF0zpT8DCkNlRX4EE6vrsco5d8XXKd4K7pGZmQV89tGYScLCbEmNkRjChF2HMEImQcfIhGf2OY7Hxs9DhAr+9Ji5PaNSGZ8qfCc2QbnUmUIj0HRa8SxkdKWtBxSSSM3lsRtCwOkr8lOb2BeS976lO9CHg.6gVgBasxbvUwc0qwMyLj23b4YHI03tIo9wMppBKnJiKld+T8c6YgLEQ5QVVxoUqc7dZMd56IT8fYgp296oGUqEEupUs9AMNb5.axSRBMR7rCbwDb4awEu55XF3Ja4SShmXjCq3uPds86sq1MsP71Dclvp8zw3RSAi3sF+A.iCt84pNNTKwP.tBY+y9vb62Jm3EHX7VGYBGaDV2DVHFxmsnwW+.dZnLKgG3HZbdbLFALnb6vA+K7KlYAbblXlERXBU5r78dtUztQwqb+5gT.LwC+uMrJ4Hbr5fyoPH4ykWApHxdtkE59eEzWc55r4BnyVKfNau.57fEPmcV.cd3BnytyUG7FYJEH75DkN.DzqFdVfLYhtN2vUgJ+GPr7wbb

[Lindon]

@ulrik - so have you tried in the default standard DAW of all developers (it seems) --- Reaper?

[ulrik]

@Lindon yes, now I have made a short test and it seems to work in Reaper :)

[Lindon]

@ulrik said in MIDI out?:

@Lindon yes, now I have made a short test and it seems to work in Reaper :)

Oooookaaay... so its possibly not: "only works in Logic",

but is instead its: "only doesnt work in Live"?

Anyone else got any other esoteric rarely used DAW (like say Cubase etc.) that can test MIDI plugins using @ulrik 's kindly donated snippet?

[ulrik]

@Lindon ok, a bit hasty there, sorry :)

[Lindon]

@ulrik said in MIDI out?:

@Lindon ok, a bit hasty there, sorry :)

well dont jump on yourself too early - lets see which other truculent DAWs there are....

[ulrik]

@ulrik Further explorations, the compiled vst3 version does NOT work in Reaper, but the vst2 does, the au version doesn't show up at all

Reaper records the MidiFX Plugins midi output, so if playing the recording back, in reaper, the plugin will not be affected (you can disable it) because the result is already on the track.

Logic record the pressed key and NOT the plugins midi output so the MidiFX plugin has to be activated when playing back the recording.

In Reaper the instrument will read the CC coming from the MidiFX plugin, and it will be recorded in Reaper

In Logic the instrument will be affected by the CC Controller values coming from the plugin, but it will not be recorded

[d.healey]

Is this option needed too?

[ulrik]

@d-healey I had it enabled when I compiled and tried the plugin before, I'm compiling right now without it enabled, I'll let you know what happens

[ulrik]

@d-healey It works the same in the plugin I tried, enabled or disabled.
(arpeggiator so it creates its own midi events, however the arp is triggered by an incoming keypress  

[d.healey]

What about this - https://github.com/christophhart/HISE/commit/65cf260b7057853c187d4a4ac1147707a83bb5c0 ?

[ulrik]

@d-healey interesting, thanks :)

[lalalandsynth]

@d-healey NIIICE!

[d.healey]

@Christoph-Hart Is this the option you referred to in another thread?

Plugin MIDI Output

[Christoph Hart]

@d-healey yes

[ulrik]

@Christoph-Hart Where do you enable it?

[d.healey]

@ulrik

[ulrik]

@d-healey Haven't that option always been there? So what is the difference now?