Scriptnode envelope ?

[lalalandsynth]

@d-healey The filter display fooled me there for a second , thought this was a solution but it behaves just the same.

[lalalandsynth]

Bipolar Modulation works correctly when set to negative.

FROM freq to zero .

BUT, when set to Positive , I dont even know what it is doing but it is not going positive from the set cutoff value, which it should.

So this is a problem , just wondering if it can be solved somehow with scriptnode.

[d.healey]

What happens if you leave the frequency knob at 20khz but you use the table envelopes points to set the frequency range?

[lalalandsynth]

@d-healey That does not seem to work either ....should it ?

[d.healey]

Seems to work for me, or I'm misunderstanding what you want

[lalalandsynth]

@d-healey Yes, that seems to work somewhat . But I cannot see how I can have a user set a filter freq on a synth and the envelope being positive from that set value...which is the correct operation?

I think this should work something like this, for modulating parameters .

[d.healey]

@lalalandsynth said in Scriptnode envelope ?:

I cannot see how I can have a user set a filter freq on a synth

You always throw a spanner in the works :p I didn't know the user needed to set the value.

You could use a knob to set the table point but table points go from 0 to 1 so I don't know what the formula is to convert that to a frequency value. I think some googling will help you with the calculation, or maybe @Christoph-Hart knows.

HiseSnippet 1303.3oc2XEsaaTDEcV6LErKIPipBk2VEQkbDkH6RRADfhSbhqrZShSrSg2plr63jQY1YV1c1PLUU7DR7mvKH9FJeC7CvmP+Cf6L6ZuqaWRcWR.RWYY44N26bOycNyYl0cCjNzvPY.xpR+g9Tj06f6MTnNt0wDl.0YSj0b3sIgJZfcroMF5SBCotHKqx2WavpxLHyyyWaCBmHbnolPnGIYNzGx7XpTqca9.Fm2l3R6y7x38JM63HEsjbYDfmx35HehyIjin6PztUBirt1VtLkLnmhnngHqY1P5Nr2wxuSD6+iXgrC4TciFndv.Eatsj6pQr92nVGy3tcGMuCQHKb2zpP43pvMwaybYismVMdOSG1oQjsdXU57fWiBBOqLvalX3cCbOm.luJsGM1tNti.VnFPfkfrvJ1WToeyB2RBdHTK6QNg1N.ZLNhZ2qd86XuZ85K8EyVc1pvBQnx9TRfceB.4sDmR4ReZC6ux1vOV9HpxzyXHTaQSa6wttX7HwDblfZOHR3nXRgsT7.g7vFZjDH40bjd9RAfo6.YiGQWZ1pOY1pUlLqKGNJaRlPUC.Z7GSDvuVdUctdpIeilh..aMZrqsnImKtjdfRxbKBmeHvupMIfzCTFrtiTQ2UTaopOoZkpOsp8K10fA41WxfwoA41sl2GbdAVSD4cHMXTMYji.AXRF10lNFlSbMIiiRQGASsqOMocJGrQNbPTRQUyFSPH3pxvEmKgK1iyboAHFLHuE1TQQFvmUM.cPmMIJxngAFQHK9z.ESOYr1jdJnVDSwqf2jFdhR5a7MYcDYU8UlzyFmvmseygoY+flgpg5Ry0LNh7XttZBUHSW5S86OVKLZv.1Y5ZwsQCXbuPEjpNdfPDxZd7AgTaW5.RDWYGdBHK.z6Snt8kFEJOoK30B3cjAdDN66otcoAN.z0Qid4cxfdhzMhSTSJxnUVS5PCtr6l06XE.nGlU480P4odtJO4tpOkv8F3tLkyw4i2R4fWX8+xFuI53yh2Zv.piJEryfa+MEUztXPYtXnbcbOPGzHdZ.xBl11eM4Tp88oBZftn13u67U6e7W94o87U+o970ccTP56GPDg9xvIF3dTOVeXSWXVi.2uc.8a2WuJm0dKIIH2td9ZsgIYtwzinhBLzk08jQB0DzixE5fzI20jw+bNUcl+CNz+heq2+bkhxSGbeE2KoxHL1i44mdvsAiyCJ4F4xwGmOAJ2VJj9GKELmrLf8ofn6QGQCxh8bmPqqTvo3oVtYy8obJIKa9Ca9PfERB11HNWnZQiouVbdqW2BGCWa8NS62LT3K+FjBeAuVdB8edbWIeXLYtMiC2r1.nJ33FMNmWdBgzhjQTgSZU7m98l6kkBLI8cwl6EA2vHSU+Y7lav7kbRPNqHm8kWbr8YlRZyB3wSpKKtdAWvpFi52EOw6Yjv0eg2i4xSsx9W+A2WVsZklwNYfg45x5KVl3VFi2Fe2UVd7ym2B95zcguF7QiMd5tnKtU8RS4p96mnwc0Rh6V3QU3qXJyZcjqN38CvIRT1ZogqN3dN7d+O.r6KiTLwQaS.4F3ETw6D40CtLuCE.pPP4PhvVkzWHOtccc63ayKbMM9S3IoyF51VIc1XTm+qjCOhSf7wNw+SBZsk21XAl2Bye0WE71511i+KDv35KWW+J6rG63nOh+ig5S9wb2BDymTfXVo.wrZAh4dEHlOs.w7YmaL5W.Z8HkzKl+CF5tU7wPVaIzmIY1Jf9K.ZRv8AC

[lalalandsynth]

@d-healey hhehe ;)

On a regular synth , the envelope on the filter will add to the cutoff position , unless of course its inverted where it will subtract from the cutoff.

As it stands it seems not possible to make the standard behaviour which rules out a lot of synth emulations, so i was hoping that until this is fixed i could hack it somehow with scriptnode.

[lalalandsynth]

Also, lots of clicks and pops when holding one note and playing another fast.

HiseSnippet 974.3oc2X0ybaaCFFTRHWU+voIwM0ciCMS9RNwDGk1IKaYoXe1xV1Tw1a9PHgDQCHfJInS0VG5P+KzsdWW5T+Oz+A8tNz09SvasaM.jTlj17jYniSpCG7422W7B9fG7vGBp9dbKruO2CnUevjwXf1GCMmvDNscPDFXi0.ZyA6g7EXO8nTqNYLx2GaCzzp9TUBs50.gWmr7pHJhYgSRA.6yIV3sHtDQR19s1jPocQ13AD2TidoVaXwYs4TdfDOUgM.iQVu.MBuMRMrJPf1M5XSDbOSARf8AZ0VkaOwzg+RVz32m3SdNEqBL.lxIJJcWN0VgX0+CZ6Pn18mtt8A.MX+DVnZDKLOrGwlbZ9D13SCKnmzQZ9PqxrfmQIgm14g2mA2BOBI3GPDN6gEdjQivdg3ag3J5uTVR+zZFYwY0r3rZwv44wFnMmIvLgZSMAj0h.ojp31ATIXxveJQSbABOqdZC0j4SDSRKpdMH0F4RpF4A7BB2aA6SDVN4i2J4fW490UMdi0.eBryvgXKQBXqA6dXY0ikCJyEAkOBZRX3PeiPfb2vX8CPGi0eJlg8TjpwLrN9ihZcLtvVG6XIj29AdHl+XtelI1D6RFvYJFII4y7wc8ve6dpc4z4ayQd4V5jk6JWj41iIRD3EJWVwkGvDYjGUKkGQ1mZRM9bLLp8NvO6M+idWdmhpECtWfka8oXzj3Nlh6vNFS4xLJLda3Z3gn.pXZ1rh7dbFerCmQrRq.RLrSg8bWPqHDxW.ljY9V6goXTZ07W1ZKoJD4I4IbI4BihyEyZ+ZAXDb0UOYp+9gCe02ib3K4INhk+2F1mSmDIl6Rnh3iaTGFELKyc.PYRFfYVIr3O9ms1MN36m+29qkyJemu0tAHZJV+e+mQ+9pjwbJxqP6HkWsWqfxl6BOcQcUo0K4F1GFg5aBGfd9YrqtUTN8KoaE.bwtU+8ur8udF2pe9mtyOzJZPgvXMj.AzdL7QMeP1qi2Yy8ae3hq6rtySZKi+lcj+Y3hpResJd3Nf3YN07bO3CWJt8lhlMaGNOm1W779FTnTofBkOO1V75kq3BvoL70Lybk0y0G79EvXWMckax0GbOGb2+G.183ABBaTOjzg56jeF+1Atlxy+agk.kwvT4MBpUQcF9n3Fp3nO.fYGF7exq3hFpXs3hFSK9V4d3hr73GI+9EgGmp7V9fvLx0MK7G9nNrmJV2.bLhFHS.gMdPCfq7f6GYYoNUv8k7S987vRzyiJQOKUhddbI5oYI54IknmuZl8n9loUBDb2H8uLQ+NQuFRqCS8NovGE.uBPaTVDM

[Casey Kolb]

The whole HISE modulation system is unipolar like this and it drives me insane. Very unusual behavior for sure.

The only hacky workaround I can think of (other than overhauling to scriptnode) is to set the backend value of the filter to the top value of the modulation range you want, but set the knob in the interface the middle of the modulation range.

Fortunately, you can achieve pretty much all of the same results with this unipolar system, but it's very unintuitive.

[lalalandsynth]

@d-healey

So basically , a knob on the synth to control freq on the filter like normal , ie. knob set to freq in properties.
This knob is also converted to 0-1 and hooked up to the table where it tracks the freq set with the Freq slider.

Then when the envelope to filter is engaged , the envelope is already set to the correct freq and when you move the freq/cutoff point you are really moving the table value , disengage and it controls filter like normal

Bunch of hoops , but possible ..However!

You cannot set the amount , the filter now always opens fully. (When the attack portion is over)

You should be able to add envelope to the set cutoff point , in the amount you want.
Basic synthesis :P

[lalalandsynth]

@Lunacy-Audio said in Scriptnode envelope ?:

Fortunately, you can achieve pretty much all of the same results with this unipolar system, but it's very unintuitive.

Can you expand a bit on this as yes , its driving me insane as well.
If I can somehow achieve a positive envelope (and preferably inverted as well) from the cutoff point , with amount setting, then please tell me how :)

[Casey Kolb]

@lalalandsynth Yes, totally agree.

I'm not using envelopes but I'm using LFOs all over the engine I'm building, so I'm not sure if the behavior is slightly different, but it's definitely unipolar in the same way.

An example to achieve the same behavior with a filter in bipolar vs unipolar:

Bipolar –

1. Set knob value to 50%.
2. Set modulation intensity to 50%.
3. Knob will modulate from 25% to 75%.

HISE Unipolar –

1. Set knob value to 75%.
2. Set modulation intensity to 50%.
3. Knob will modulate from 25 to 75%.

Obviously that's a pretty stupid example haha, but you can achieve mostly the same results with either. The latter is just more confusing.

[Casey Kolb]

For something like a macro control, it typically works as a positive unipolar modulation (i.e. starts at 50% and adds the modulation intensity) which I think is what you're referring to.

A good reference point: Serum treats macro modulators this way, but treats LFOs as bipolar sources. I'm sure you already know all this though.

[lalalandsynth]

Yes, I am referring to how almost all analog synths work when you add an envelope to the filter ...hehehe :)
Everything would be so much simpler if HISE would just stick to how this works normally.

Now obviously this might be fixed (I certainly hope so ) but I was hoping I could do it via scriptnode as it appears to me that the envelope system is unworkable as it stands.

[lalalandsynth]

Normal Bipolar LFO to filter behaviour, and in fact it does the same for Pitch .
As you can hear , it adds and subtracts from the set cutoff point.
link text

Normal Positive going envelope FROM cutoff point, only adding to it ! Unless you swicth the invert button in which case it will subtract from the cutoff point.

link text

Another example
link text

[Casey Kolb]

100%. I'm with you haha

[Lindon]

..and theres definitely a click in the envelope...

[Christoph Hart]

Does the click go away if you wiggle the hold knob? I remember a glitch there that appeares sometimes...

[Lindon]

@Christoph-Hart nope - sorry it doesn't.