Something is wrong with colour blending when opacity is involved

Matt_SF

HiseSnippet 1056.3ocsWstaaaCElxNLq1qWVA5CfP9kCPWfcVW2JJFlquMXrkDi5thseUPKQKyEIRCJpT6Nz+rmr9Tzmi8FjcntXQkHmo3sj.DDd34xG+34b3QSjBGZXnPhrZ7l0KoHq6imtlqVzeAgwQiGfrdH9DRnhJsSD0a8RRXH0EYYU+mzBrZrGJ9m+9G6Q7IbGZtHD5sBlC8WXALUtzIc+Ylu+HhK8Mr.CseV2wNBdeguHBvScbazRhy4DO5oDsZ0vHq8G5xTB4TEQQCQV60S3td5Bw64I5+VVHalOUunCZJ3nDwiD9tZDqkh5uf46NI6bGh.uLImEpmvBOAeByksQdNa7UwaXmagIeXUqH7pW.dcLgWaC3UBjrLfzdIP5w3oNR1RU9NZ77k3wb3xYNAncSnjnKp1mqg6K.M3piBHmSGIgEarn0ya29o1veN7kMaBTenx9BhztGv5dRQD209Gryr1ip5KBVJ3vhVGjqxAfs4ld1r+f5n1pYIaePwvMaiu7jz0fssWMZzwCgeG.5kGoiBopIv8f50hHEiSaMOh6nXBdKuCa9mMa3czbHs5U99sJ5QHZeTGwjfWcuzd0KdQBLx7PyqcRSuQ+WNvoZEetax39PXsyBqsfWPIsejB+VNYN4oP37inwfK6H.oTY5krI.Pv2UBCZBH039DeeMW0pbLb3KM.4oBE8LdqXXz7iMsu5VymW5dotxmJKcacC.4MYXKdTvLpzjDzJBUEEK0vauTyrSfSBCYnnfOlyTmsjx2V+ATJsBkk0SQE7ep3hxGlVT1KRoDbDCp8dDt.WhhAtYKQTkbhonN2BmL0m4RkEbRhnxbxuNd.QQz8aROiv4dIUpXZJ0Z.8Bn4cR2mF3AzvyUhkwjPZtE7ZQRvePVuIBm5GG66iyKbQqLC5ZyEum4pVrQvm9qtKnLuEJSIyDR.8SYen.zSj9ZhKKJrfbur2OZr+kWdYrLlhFjKMSyboGaJVQWottKPFm48q7UeUO2ne+pmaPBpJzbSbZdPnYvXcWat3JAicsfw5tU5rTxubNZKDZ4reY2SExr9hJWarxj0tsr7RhDBmQbMXTz1gyMTk8e5Rupv4QaKg3doofUGFklNb2TEc6JkuItfxIPAV7jNWj0o2pN55SMAyqIbi7IphCwombMcC34lBSNomNhGxTqMmr8+sI6pJDeLdBS4rnbLVqDLBkO2EXLcd3GfGNeNjVkCv8vi9s6lgeQISl4cBQIYPZL9znfoPljCEhNGRz0O2aUS2TNYca8ZMCLkxciW.IbWltYG8ZqzM6jsIJf3HEuyYSsk08hk.XhG+wFMfu5AVau4USLt8QsQAvv+uywQe7+ZXVgxs43cvluYGr4Y6fMe6NXyy2Aa9tcvlu+FsQ+cWuJRIBRJG.ASFFO8hk0v7tAn+AvMm79H

Just change the hex alpha value of the backgroundgrey "manually"

d.healey

@Matt_SF I don't see a difference.

@tomekslesicki's is on the left, yours is on the right

Matt_SF

@d-healey ah, that's odd... here's what I get

tomekslesicki

Thanks guys, I'm getting the same problem with Matt's snippet, unfortunately.

@d-healey maybe you're right about the opacity stack, but then if 1 is 100%, isn't it a bug that if a semi-transparent layer is overlayed on top of a layer that already is fully visible, the opacity can go above 100%?

d.healey

@tomekslesicki Yes it does seem a little strange

Christoph Hart

Alright, either my monitor is not calibrated correctly or I'm getting blind, but I don't see any difference and this entire topic looks like a big prank to me :)

Can somebody make a clear example that shows the difference like night and day type (and not a colour that is 0xFF292929 but should be 0xFF292928.

tomekslesicki

@Christoph-Hart it's not about night and day, it's just that if it's about creating an impression of a half-opaque panel with controls, it doesn't look good if there's suddenly a rectangle overlaid on top of the panel.

Christoph Hart

@tomekslesicki But where is the rectangle? I don't see a rectangle.

d.healey

@Christoph-Hart

But where is the rectangle? I don't see a rectangle.

Must be a monitor (or eyeball) setting issue :p the rectangle is subtle. I'll see if I can make a clearer example.

d.healey

This post is deleted!

d.healey

Ok here's something interesting.

Alpha values

0.1 = No rectangle
0.2 = No rectangle
0.3 = Rectangle
0.4 = No rectangle
0.5 = Rectangle
0.6 = No rectangle @tomekslesicki Maybe just use this value
0.7 = Rectangle
0.8 = No rectangle
0.9 = Rectangle

Here I have taken the same snippet as before and adjusted the contrast in an image editor

tomekslesicki

@d-healey thanks, David, you're way better at explaining things than I am!

Christoph Hart

@tomekslesicki Ah finally - actually I think that the PNG compression of the screenshot makes the differences even more subtle, but now I have finally proof that you aren't executing an elaborated prank :)

Alright, the minimal use case to demonstrate this issue is:

const var Background = Content.getComponent("Background");

const var backgroundgrey = 0xFF333333;

Background.setPaintRoutine(function(g)
{
	g.fillAll(backgroundgrey);
	g.setColour(Colours.withAlpha(backgroundgrey, 0.6));
	g.fillRect(this.getLocalBounds(50));
});

I've deliberately used a pure grey in order to rule out rounding errors. For me, 0.6 creates the most visible rectangle. Curiously, in a raw JUCE component, it doesn't show that rectangle, so I'll try to check where the error comes from.

Christoph Hart

Curiously, in a raw JUCE component, it doesn't show that rectangle

Nope, my weak eyes struck again, it's actually the same when using raw JUCE.

auto grey = Colour(0xFF333333);

g.fillAll(grey);
g.setColour(grey.withAlpha(0.6f));
g.fillRect(getLocalBounds().reduced(50));

Also shows up that box. Now it gets complicated :)

Christoph Hart

I've posted it in the JUCE forum, let's see how it goes.

https://forum.juce.com/t/subtle-colour-error/52177

I wouldn't hold my breath that there is an easy solution for this though...

Something is wrong with colour blending when opacity is involved

21

1.8k

10.4k

90.8k