Pretty weird problem with the Preset Browser ?

ustk

Bottom of the third post:
https://forum.hise.audio/topic/2555/scriptnode-breaking-changes/3
But it seems compromised since @Christoph-Hart isn't working on it for a moment...

Lindon

@lalalandsynth said in Pretty weird problem with the Preset Browser ?:

@d-healey said in Pretty weird problem with the Preset Browser ?:

@lalalandsynth I don't use the broken parts. The stock preset browser and its controls work fine, but if you try to use the api functions you'll meet the bugs. Save/load, next/previous, etc. are buggy or just don't work.

Do you always use 3 columns as renaming does not work for me using 2 columns ?
And that is just the stock browser.

I've never come across ANY problems with the Preset Browser - and I've implemented fwd/back buttons that use the API - but I've ALWAYS used the 3 column version - maybe that's the issue?

lalalandsynth

@Lindon The 3 column one I am using does not show one of the selected presets when the preset browser is open and you are scrolling through using prev/next, it loads it ,admittedly usually its closed when using the prev next. .......So with the preset browser closed you might not even notice it , but when using Prev/next and you hit the one it skips , the name in your getCurrentUserPresetName and the one in the preset browser will not match when its opened.

Potentially very confusing for a user.
SEE GIF.
3 column display.gif

HiseSnippet 3088.3oc6a07aabbEeWIM1VLVxNNoAsnWVv1CRvNxb4GhjwMvq9hNxQRjVT1wtoANi1cH41rbW58CYSGXTglKsmZO1.zCFs+Cjy8jZuUfdnn8efbr.Env+Gj9lY1k6r7CIJ4OhUaXfMx9lYd6u2Gy68l2rtlqiNwyywURd5c51gHIedT8t19sVoE1zVZ8UkjeKz8vM6hUpaZPzoTUJJsb2NXOOhgjr7j2fNQ4omRh86YWeYrE1VmDSRR5NNl5jMLaa5GSsl1GZZYUAaP1wrsvryqstti8JNVNA.nlDkQpCV+yvMIagoSaBjj7YVyvz2wstO1m3IIO0xNFcq2x4g174eGSOycsHzGTkpCLhSthikAEwTpRqzxzxnVjv6IIIipEqJljqJdazllFl8nGqRtHa.k3UHpOjm3vfmpH7xL9vSV.dSwg2ahpq6Z1wOdDJ1dCz519D2FXvDHBK9bkl3OeVzJNvLr8WnM9yHUbgG5sh4JoV9JJKple9qMSJ5+c0qpTsCwFDUhGwm976dr+Q4CXR87U1C6pzAaSrTUdekHTfMLpQoMWZ9PouhRoL.HxPwvUuZ7J4XXUSuNV3tBLnIweEm1cbrgGlKchYklyCkO9l0qtU3q9Sn3IZsvTA0WGhquIwCzEsoST.Ie9LoTTR+PSC+VoeOkEyk+JLBsHlMa4CTxqlkSwzmzl6zBTyzOsrThyj5Ib0pnP0B1UQcNRpPVNv22wdtzQixji3EA.1lKmiTMDOkzB1RtdnkgCiqexQpGD3xUTJjg+GtNwEaX5bCWmfNfrkNS5dR2LoLssLsIJMBr08McrUbri4C8E55XMmcP6cItWADGq.x7yjhwT9OtxeAO.gQylOqqo.uD5KHlcKDyxUvVV6BgJlaHutH8N0GZOErsgxVjG4G5Qov01dmbu6gaB1kw1kbccd31L2k4GNZ6edIv7f5xQL84zidyCnTMavUfJu+6qnNOmF+uWytIv8ErbvFTExs8HtbcxbMvVdDJDdRnQ8HkwMHMFGQjNswWBEl8yq.RM8lNAdCJjWSbEO4ERPNF+2.uKwZj6PElS5QuygOq5VPf.2CSQnDs+IRinLWnrSeqAttvzikbZtz4lmptRmd93cdJiCToV34R6CtKPLgzpLryWLAzlOOL6HAb7qh6Wx++NrWCWwMJ2xgnb4VBJiELBa43SpZO27o97TSm5IoFXnFMF5Xgrzh3Nzgo083dXKrufjQSDJ.HYEFnQWggXAP5b8jvDcrW21zmlfeT0cHEpbgJPlNDUvT8Y0eLaX8Gb8mjITlwERPRUhA7vZ6d5Ws0eRS5XyjrIXxA+sb+iS.SxkfIe8eLyGdvwmI4SvD9uQwDdJkDLgSRsel7rqGyjo3LYlvUrClZEo7XVQJpChCCrOVRlfJlcgj+1qZit3GTN2FVcKtBixFk2ZoK2nvM6r3JrwsWduMt7tePPS131Uu6daemKWqwkWnHeb3ufGfek4OOVx7ah5KF9IS0cIT+I6NF7QvNNKRbm9P3wsWeUpFDpSNzeOtXHf1pPhCcBun6oQqR79LemNfgsWzFI4ylzxsda3.KIrbLJpROR701U7AVMl8H7690Z7ZL6QIyWn0vzJ7TPWF8401t5MWakctekpar5Za+D9YzpDXYo3Y9XhRAEnT9E5X2jpf5AyY7COXCGTUf7h9l1M2wLzO66MjAR.ZMsXPq8.sjf9qw8CZselVnBM5vkK8AqVe6a3h6zRZ2lhmxKtX49eNK8PMKVnXlLkJmqnDMYQzDmFsXobEJVNuDy9I+dHdwo8BgstAs5T1KERurGwBLqPc8rIstsA4QvvuqJjMQ38kSRNERMetLpEKjOg567icfuXU19UDTYOseUlzOteUlz8z5Did5Vo9PObdXWvI.NwFc3ygVx2GxlI0FG+N+U+SMO+tzL.oP2g5FqisRpPmFoppVJeI0D58oQ4xUnP974NQRcVQottfT+UGsTevcOVR8Ygcg53tuDE5KL1YVdjn29wRn2+3IzSipG34S6AgnXC+ZK1.l6cPaGiv.U5lPQVvvFFVjZNdlzxKhm45G7sfSRdA8kxtuj0WaSrHXOxKQ2jTicZeg8FKIH1ROtew9ZCDQXAs3PkPjoEKVrXV0Bi.ciPT7.wjTAq6yZ0Gqdru7K+qWeHlviUxAw87JsDjqCtSex0AOd.4ROYxgKfVJvvzYIarUWnveg7CCS5nISxVJegREKsX4xIEaPIkKWw7EyqlHaAS2snZlbEBSWjaDoKBQP+IJxRySbHN8BV+yih6Agno+Ahl9h8oh1e0ATQum1wHKIkfn7ReFpYnsmOfNdIIx+vApbv2Ea6wpTvCuGY8HPyVsnvdtjk3v5YGSVOGh2wFpbhjqwKrAI+SDJp4LOdBt7zS9NyuWlSIgW7YhBokzKtGY4IFMfFQMWYGUtXob8o9+W+x9U+e5izfHJvKS7sFIswUi8iFPmF1XIOcWBw9ERUXh4Y1WLOizp8IFOcfMZO0s+MZb7sLTUcxMZz5dJmqPFU091okOaoREUKmsXgjlF5HkyWt.DlIZS0eHbSE8bl0AOJ9tBX6iua.4J8Fh0ua2dCxZES7nziU6MHY54dC6V2fLDumiK.N50GjXvsBn3MnMaM4n6gE2jjP1Fs0dHa6OxioEawx3JXw1+98Yw9sdCTNzGqMfZVMGD2uXFHImXNvKh1nRUkMcLBrvPrcUAiYnsYwhYKWXPyoZg7EJjMmjuiikuIbblyfLBfBG1S75IFx9+w5zdBkm7KNrHdRYGHhWYsiSHKSuMcZCvC61MpEFiChGxAKELV6+sGjmNoqEqKYLDOCRnuYBf8.h1vNFIR1VHZKRtB7D0qmpM1h7vnNemL+HKN62P4RCHbQc3Xjwb95ZCAlG8QsYoDjhRIj.f5I.3Ugm545IOIwltEhcwUCGgRCdeXWD0aaf3U0QuexvAnk+JdmXz68xFJKtqX6Xdob+ciKbeSTMSe8VCGuSLD7RyI9RFug2F5Ln0Zzfn6GC1oPUt6qfq9bBArf3XIEpWUh767rWIaIvyxA.hcS5HefF6h.HOLreNgjunl7jIA+jiWWUGhtaam.ZZ6MwPDA5F.HATcv8Um.pNaHaBsksxzBhBeNSzdi5DaC1CeC7KbPU5yxgCpFMnn84b8t3dy1crH2Hx7LaHAEJE0C4N6gZHHV3DNUeTxXd2SaH2p+5vwtb8q4Xgc62k7EkpTdpwdeCUjTdd1mO434rdD2M+rbPhnokCC.0WB5iDXUbIOHfXqGQb++8s.hXCn173VM7az9Hn1pFNtsS5G+rquAoI7hDorCABbWuqstnMpdaGG+VrpKE+7KdasMbb5rVT32XlTqEbR5pMZvNaPLaVIvy2ocDVdU0C559jN7pM+Xzh4WH434p9h4YoigGxQ3FOwX5F+VLmkddET2lWySXwQbOW1SAH9RHVzNkSM0DbIDKZ7oG.eQTMr8qAv8Ubd3vP+uAj10lv9H5XZi2g8rBMDoxMH1D2ASCjLc7eeb+D55L1eBcU08gW+NzyfzwwKAiqSZatCTVumHwa6Qnao2lZ9RDs2A6NzgfDTfPNz0TG6G3x7CVpsSfs+gUnvTiWD1infwods9S46U2IWdwTQyE3X7r7lsGVsU+MdWDaaR+.rZ4XalndisIvtvlMIthHdnhA+BsVIvcORxZT0wcGfZ3seI7IFvorAAfl3D+.vnL.6D+pBhtbEguQfn6OP.bqo6rI+9UNIp8inLAzX5ZLS3k9ov12+5cxfYivJ2h75MXOO+dEOMnWuPzsAdpPwNazcwcZP0dnMgYxSaMg4ESVfv+0AbIDbd+t7n6ULs7Ca.yzH9CYOztLLvAa+KW9KztknYOYn0EztU.1JglVQaYyNzNNLVVgW98c3cPIN5y+607gOsQi+yX27guu12tMe31nEyLPyG1Ys673R67yq9fRzC2e2p+T7MyTVnYBq2p4thMWnWy.B+8cMa36Z1vyQpjm69R9JEu+.TX7UlV9zCtmEcq+OogCuJdGsw5tN2Wm+g0RCobNFEPtsYevCSi1j9rRuuDYDJyBYnenYl2WWmVSx6B5mgulrmf0j6Drl7mf0T3DrlEOAqo3IXMkNz0PahwRAPxPt+OPn1Z7bVxqEeUpR+W.7tdUr.

The renaming issue is definitely a 2 column problem, It will allow renaming 10% of the time , which just makes it stranger :)
But there is also the weird behaviour when using the next prev in the 2 column where it jumps back to directory ..see gif.
Preset 2 Columns prev next.gif

lalalandsynth

BTW,. tested the renaming on the VST version of B3 Collab Organ which has 2 columns , and renaming does not work.

ustk

@lalalandsynth I might have found the problem for the 2 columns renaming issue

Not sure for the prev/next selection issue though…
Can you please tell if this happens in 2 columns mode as well?

lalalandsynth

@ustk You mean 3 columns mode as well ?
I tested 3 columns the other day , no renaming problem there but I will verify .

ustk

@lalalandsynth Ok so I fixed the 2 columns renaming issue as well as preset highlighting inconsistency on prev/next (for both 2 & 3 cols)
Although I'm still struggling with preset disappearing on prev/next in 2 columns mode...
But it's late and night is the mother of counsel! I'll have fun with that tomorrow :)

lalalandsynth

@ustk excellent !!

ustk

Ok so now it's working, so I'm trying to extend this to the 1 column style that is broken too...

lalalandsynth

@ustk Are you somehow fixing this within Hise or in c++ ?

ustk

@lalalandsynth In the source code so C++

lalalandsynth

@ustk yep, thought so , sweet !

ustk

Now everything works except I have just noticed another bug. (actually, we can see it in your screen gif)
In 2 columns mode, you can't rename the Bank...
Taking a pause then back on it :)

ustk

Ok so after scrutinizing the code for hours, I need help for this one (rename & delete don't appear in 2 columns mode)

I know it is because listbox->getNumSelectedRows() > 0 returns false for some reason... But what reason is beyond my skills

void PresetBrowserColumn::updateButtonVisibility()
{
	editButton->setVisible(false);

	const bool buttonsVisible = showButtonsAtBottom && !isResultBar && currentRoot.isDirectory();
	const bool fileIsSelected = listbox->getNumSelectedRows() > 0;

	addButton->setVisible(buttonsVisible);
	deleteButton->setVisible(buttonsVisible && fileIsSelected);
	renameButton->setVisible(buttonsVisible && fileIsSelected);
}

lalalandsynth

@ustk What do you mean by "delete" not appearing in 2 columns ?
Delete works for me...

Although its annoying that if I delete it goes back to category and I have to select that to see the presets again.

EDIT: This going back to category is another sometimes issue..?

ustk

@lalalandsynth said in Pretty weird problem with the Preset Browser ?:

@ustk What do you mean by "delete" not appearing in 2 columns ?
Delete works for me...

Bottom of the left column, there are no Rename and Delete only in 2 columns mode:

Although its annoying that if I delete it goes back to category and I have to select that to see the presets again.

EDIT: This going back to category is another sometimes issue..?

Will check that tomorrow, might be a lucky day :)

lalalandsynth

@ustk Ah, You mean delete and rename Category ! hehe.
I hadnt even noticed that yet ....indeed

ustk

@lalalandsynth Yep, I meant:

In 2 columns mode, you can't rename the Bank....

:)

ustk

The preset browser is fixed. Although I'm a C++ noob, so it certainly could have been done in a better way, so feel free to make it better and teach me at the same time :)

Here's my fork so it can be tested before I make a pull request to Dave's fork:
(My fork is up to date with Dave's one, so only the preset browser is different...)
https://github.com/ustk/HISE/tree/develop

Still, the last remaining issue is that Rename and Delete buttons don't appear in the bank column when in 2 columns mode. I still need help with this one...

d.healey

@ustk Good work, I'll have a look later today and see if I can track down the rename/delete buttons.

Pretty weird problem with the Preset Browser ?

18

1.8k

10.4k

90.9k