Issue macro taking the priority

[David Healey]

@ustk said in Issue macro taking the priority:

@Christoph-Hart Any new on this?

Yes, it's broken :)

https://forum.hise.audio/topic/14165/latest-version-of-hise-breaks-existing-presets

[ustk]

@David-Healey Oh I see water ran under the bridge while I was away...
HISE_MACROS_ARE_PLUGIN_PARAMETERS=1 is indeed not helpful here because they're all exposed...

@Oli-Ullmann solution of connecting knobs directly to the modulator doesn't fully work either (and they are inverted, with the table be of no use because the modulator state is "Not assigned")

• I thought about using a constant modulator but, is it still existing? I can't see it...
• Another solution I might explore is a Script Time Variant Modulator

But anyway this needs a proper fix

[Oli Ullmann]

@ustk said in Issue macro taking the priority:

state is "Not assigned"

Do you mean that the mode [“Scale,” “Unipolar,” “Bipolar”] is not initialized when you establish a modulation connection?

To do this, you must first use setMatrixModulationProperties to specify the default mode for the modulation for the corresponding target.

You can use getMatrixModulationProperties to see what form the json object has in order to define the properties. I can also create a snippet for you. :-) Just let me know...

And yes - constants still exist! :-)

[ustk]

@Oli-Ullmann No, I was talking about this:

Making a very simplistic Script Time Variant Modulator works well enough to fake a macro using stock knobs with processorId / parameterId

Oh yeah mad bad, Constant modulators are voice start... not for me since I'm making an FX...

[DanH]

@Oli-Ullmann don't want to hijack this thread but do you have an example of how to use setMatrixModulationProperties to set initial mod values?

[Oli Ullmann]

@DanH
I'm at the gym.
Will make you a snippet when I'm back at my computer.

[DanH]

@Oli-Ullmann Thanks!

[ustk]

@DanH If you trace ModMatrix.getMatrixModulationProperties(); you'll see how the object is built

[DanH]

@ustk Will do - So every knob that you want to modulate you need to set this? And does anyone know which option suits which type of modulation / situation?

[ustk]

@DanH I do not really understand that selector in scriptnode, I set everything to Combined and it seems to work fine for me

https://docs.hise.dev/scriptnode/list/core/extra_mod.html

[DanH]

@ustk said in Issue macro taking the priority:

https://docs.hise.dev/scriptnode/list/core/extra_mod.html

How is the extra_mod node supposed to be used?

[ustk]

@DanH Once you have set a parameter as External Modulation you just have to set the corresponding index to the extra_mod.

You don't need to wire the parameter anymore since it is connected internally with the extra_mod. Then wire the extra_mod like any other modulator node

The indexes are in the same order as the parameters are set
Here the fourth param is idx 3:

[DanH]

@ustk Christ.... Ok so if my parameter called Freq 1 is connected to my Filter Freq node's frequency knob, and I set Freq 1 to External Modulation "combined" (or whatever), then I should now remove the connection, create an extra mod node, set the index accordingly and connect that to the Filter Frequency knob instead?

[ustk]

@DanH Exact

[ustk]

@DanH Then on the interface side, the slider shouldn't be connected to the scriptFX parameter anymore but directly to the Matrix Modulator Value parameter:

From there, everything is linked internally
UI slider -> MM Value -> Network Param -> extra_mod

[DanH]

@ustk Thanks. Great, 100 knobs to reconfigure!

[Oli Ullmann]

@DanH
In this small snippet, you can see how to set the properties. Unfortunately, I believe that you have to do this for each modulation target.

I connected the UI slider in this snippet to the ScriptFX parameter. If monophonic modulation is sufficient for you, you can do the same and won't need external modulation. Otherwise, you have to do it as @ustk writes.

Here you will find all the information you need to set properties:
https://docs.hise.dev/scripting/scripting-api/scriptmodulationmatrix/index.html#setmatrixmodulationproperties

Snippet:

HiseSnippet 2242.3oc6YrsaabbcVRMxVz0AwMtHEEn.KT5CRsBBh5hcbCJzZcg1DQThUjVI.8A2Q6NK4.s6La2KxhNv.En8A+RQereK8s7AjBDT+Cz9Gj9EjdlY1k6thLTzrxJH.kDffy4LyYNmybtMmocnvlFEIBQF05NHfhL9Q3NC3w82sOgwQM2CYr.1W3rG0Wf1YP.IJh5fLLp9DIZiElCo97MauCwivso4fPnSDLa5ALeVbNz1VeJyyqAwg1k4WX1aZ0zVv2U3IR.VoJdMT.w9LRO5gD4zpfQOkD0GY7KwqsoM4iW2cqM13QO5ga4bJ01sN8zGZSVaKh6VD.5ljM2p9lHi422gEKB6DShoQ.Q2Q3LnSewK35M3DVD6TOpbPcTGXm0fQ61m44zNSuDg.B0NWKUUqktOtEygMDdt158UHLyWQQklQkIwR0eKXIiBrzbZV5d3N1grf3bLR94N3l7XZnKANaJxJ54hp7Wpf2U.yfGupO4LZiPXvvUrzCVasULgeV9SpUaedOFmtJwwokvIwipDhthmEQCaGRinwKs3S7DmR7LU3IfbZJIMnYng0WDHAbBGEa56a9aLSIlcHEHR57YBdKRbH6hqjPYTR3zjyhkLRRDPzunlo4hcndT6XBnF6.1RflXwesYbXBcEIx8ntjDuX4pNg3knPJWEfZ2jXgqKriCAA.ggTX7hcrIdzEWICrTAwiXwC.b0Wcsb3QGJB8IdrWRcR2VEpWA+9JECbLg2iBmPAzvX1vs+U0dUsZ99qBJQsFHWijO2kJItRs.nThDdzUCBY73khCkmX.U5MQpr7xK+ItIbaIXSA+PQL8H9RKW6Kps.vElWFkq6XwIOOBEddzvwhV5bGNoEtDOw+TZ3JlmKOFFNQvXtrGx7SmGhs1DtvDEbot5n.Z53FBOGoku7+i5OgR8AjdVobHL0Xke06k5W0wi4PCQLfH2B+obwo0QJlOKHl0e+eZgdVy8HwjLx.TLWyCv1idNDRT6tt.dOZzYwh.0b8CDb49a7dW4ldwvnl+wyrFjGBka4ybb7nsEfkInrkXpJQD72rhhoAc.qxhQr8KF.eSKeRNge8arhRbcY.DL17ouDAldTYrjFgz+PBkaO.Ejo8Z5nxYn3VyFedcHvcHDyFhfHwbar1uB4qrH6RBAqSIh6fG5vgXwT+rP+KLOB8st5bEiDhCBtlEQnXDWYtnba8Rg4F5oVTxeKBCu1DCCOsr38vsYw18GOOVYL7HX.8tfGSSdcW79ttPPxbFbNbiOeVyTM8a+s0a+OCqCumqnxBtq3keNdBQ+mPMHe8zVCRvTWCxkiFM64qm6cUIDyMcGLWQ3uozN9CF4nI5FzaqTQO2SylX7AMNJUqA+Kmwpe0L1Nr.gGIThOOt1P721RZgzL2.y5uZ8YjyotPF9zH3CozAzdvdVDRWJDQGJj1tnwXGegHtOi2qrc28sNPHB1mKqYwoHQZ2mDIy.CkEThL.Y6JZQff5g65IrOqHxl83hPpNqdQ36lDEK7yD.UE0cfjBprUF+N7C1bU3i6uR96i1E9YiitdFit9p4sxTakJsDFdjKsId6sRug8qjb7Pive.vwSLiV0oJi10N+N6Y2tdXkiEIwfyst1aHzzgI95qf.bBmS8fMBaTQ5KpGulbrxglxcTC9V3SJx5xwFoHqmgDoIttFyhx9Gpk86fkd3pKvqj7eBNyi27ITH+4nQFemmC8H3xXmS6FR3QAhHZ8RQxn9rtPguQkfdoUr9XWQIn6QiS3kIsFToYIUEM.UQ8hA4y.tdQfsI7RDCFWhRsX40Ji9WaqCc2gBRtyQQ1fhQpmKEIOwKh9YLm390KtvbvqWD7SIgNWN2gQ0o1jsXXzxkFWX92js43FMxz2iWGnTAJKjwicX9Adz84mS8fqBp3weLNsQDYPK6S1RvEA8EbVIKfiofqeudzRFViUfdbbLoXUA225XpGEpkHGzuv5.ndZRXK0E6lIcwaeGpF640OEqYWSYfDy+WN29+I.u4ud23Nlqk1M.XOkadolCLlVPZ7ZbdChBBoAjPZWQaOxfkhHRWmiAdbEySkU5J6gwncUJsWD6HmwR1oIamklOM+0jw+MRo.CaYE5PZ7KDgmoNNR+ObYastORojet6E0QO1yS7BYqlXoVrvYfBVag2fr3MFU0yHiSeruHQ1WJM6latuS1wQFm+TRTWByS1PiNIQA.qdDuCPGUwDFUOgFFo1yagWaU3K3MbnJ1ysZPrAc9f1DnlEvsxN6t9qZOz9sjXTzDR+5.kPKoZV8GZNCDHeUu0j24ANMam0fJYK4pXTsPK5z1yxQfmaE8V2L5DIVahG5Dc+9.UgbWz5akPLubpXbz4tnRhycwtLO4NspD0nbtdISlkKyfRTfOwEYsYrgl94+Ux2bG5EY1I6Cl5NP.D8M8RscJnBj48yFAhaKF+jhc0TVRWKxEkg852X0YjNJB1mmQegV7SgZ8m7+GaqeEh7aX2kdQbWghffI74ffI23hynMom9Me5jb5SBEIApAkYA313o4PGAdSMQUp4Gm.25knGTAUPPqcIA0ZiMdy1WRP+xu5q9noSPQez+4qUBZU7u86T.eFbr3BV1NSk.BI3Fq.Bvmjb.eV+KG4.Cs9TJGpZJ.4XdUUTeGhhr001rSodSmfHKFebBhpv5IIHP7lQDjuY6oRP98evduI0xaXWWtVNXr92u7OOtCFE7YPdd+wbv.x3DNXTkrcMYi8N+nYRhxB3rddcC5wniwmKa2UxICekhq+nevoU4P66eAru7gc+VkSrFdOVjVULdAc7x0lVWcrzhACGQLTuREmpJOJJ8QqRGlleV9TM5jTsK9rNE2AzNBwY9DU8Gyz6eM82rCt28ObtgvGhOJxdcS00DL+9+dB2DkjdSrG9D6Pwys0UxKMZusBBH2bUIUKfaIGadoWmU9wm4vdtscYRMxBWeVW3Fy5B2bVW3Vy5BevrtvGNqK7iu5EJ6nTZ8ZR+DHES680UsZL7wQLph9uKuIxIB

All the best
Oli

[ustk]

@DanH

[Oli Ullmann]

@DanH
And here is the whole thing again with a macro modulator:

@ustk maybe this is also interesting for you...

HiseSnippet 2356.3oc2Y0saabbEdHoVYK5313lTjh.TfEJ8BoBABQIJKmFTnU+QYBGIwHRIazaTGs6rjC3tyrc+QRzAFn.sW3aJ5k4YoW07.jBDT+Bz9.Tfzm.2yLytb2UjlhlUVAIzvBbNyeem+OygM84ljf.tOpP4188HnBumVq9rvta2ESYnF6fJLmlK2ZGhKGsUeObP.wBUnPo8DSWXtYPxOe2FagcvLSRJID5DN0j74TWZXJ0lFOg53TGaQZScyr5ZFML4rs4N7H.JkzVF4gM6g6PN.KVVQMziwAcQE90ZKWyD+nUrWa0U+zOc80rNiXZWkb15l3kWCauFFnVCWasp0PElcWKZH2uUHNjD.G5Vbq9s5xufotfSnAzybHhAUQsfaVQFscWpiUyD4R.BNnloRoRJozGpsO0hNfdpz58kSnmtirBsBEGGjp9V.oBYfzLJH8.sVl9TuvzYD34dZMXgDeaLnaxBE0ZQE+KE01lCqfEVwE2iT2GFLXGK7vkWdIc3OK9YkKuKqCkQpfsr1maE4PjLQa9wAD+l9j.R3ByumC+LritbdLvm5hiFjLD+pyCGAngCB0cc0+s5wGloOANj30S4r8wg9zKu1CJ4j3VMXzPAPhBfC8KKqqOeKhCwLDChwVfsDHIl+2nG5GQVRL4NDabjSnXWmfchjSJ1EL01Qgbaa3FGPBHBCIv34aYhcHyuTBYg.hEPC6CyUsxxozCNf66hcnOmXEesxodA72WHAvQXVGBng7H9gzAW+KJ+hxkccq.BQkDHUhjt1ExwtBo.HTB3NjJd9TV3Bg9BMFbJcF6or3hK9Y1QLSAYcN6.dH4P1BKV9KKOGfB8qNks8HmSnO74NND+QNsv41ebabAVj6YD+kzOWnFFrPvXNuGxrSlGhoxDNyB4Lgr5POR735bGKgku36C6Ogh8A.OqhwHDVZnzu5mD6W0xgZQ7QT3Pti1SX7yphjfOIHlwe6eZfl3MuR9MKBghNtwN3Prv6NFNopMf1Njyg3oJe84z1gDzKj6IwqqGmI.ege50h3KGbg+wdF8SuclgK0xxgzjCl0flRLSIwDdekQPHwqEXRmEqtYi9WyvEmdvu7UFAQ11Tfhll9ieNBraIh.Q08I+gHByrOxKQz2vRlvQhV85OqJD02GB3CgeDybWMkSIxUZN2F6Cl1hItm1.uUDMj3lj2XtYQnWaK.QH4xP4Abb6CqWWneGHjl6Z0LuAgj9EFW4x9Ou9qRur6ns+laezgCA1xZ6iM84Brliu+XEc8XSlzfcWQJ7dp0IiWAIPGJtOjwIYmYSCIRPmF.HWr+AguxpQeKxMs7XyMMoP7AZMoglcGMFKNBLJbNeGfw3L52WaWaaHyQJ.mQq9yl1z2S90eW00+wZpbdoBpjLdRr7K0FSJwwTX12NoEl4MwElc0PzSeQLy7tptpYlLEy0jSXBsi+fgTMA2hda4pDbtAvLNhiBORXNlvMWKZ2h5wcv9h4gx8ZikHK0dRdvMXVjKyRskKmG1Mu0D0PtV4IHy0Ipr+Fqp3ajHOklnHO23VXSeTnaFnbDOJjx5nJbDxbePjqp9Y.ILFwAtHsBEEUJoFurXrTMSXVxAuF9DOYUw3BwSVMYRj5vyTiCiXpJ13NiN299xJGhuGIZhsxTjFos5lQWdESwu6uKoMBsZC14P4UJwZVkwGoTF2S6o3yIxmCKUE+b4XanDe88HPf2g8ddmG78P3oMmSZ6iYAd7.R0bNbDWZanHmfbTuxNVYj6HG0cHgQr7GshTtUIDE0AQQl0cWiDhqjkXSLK2gAiycR6Synr9WarKS93MBv4VGFXBBFYLrLp3lQNAjmRsB6VM6FSIuRVxOF6aA5PybtyklXenrgbxWSUl0ea1zfa0jaeOVG4nyr0h554P1Ebbcf2FIw3OSK9Y8ITy6StOmw85xYzbV.GQfXQc5PxYXM5.JggXydoT9PiiHNDbPF+zekwmCEhg8UwqlJYwae+dFo95WnofqtHPh9+O5saUyrebkQ9lwjOVdUN9cpvcJt7buVdDMzqvK0Ra2hmOAdJIoMuoCt+BAXgqyQ.FWR+LGtYOwi5GtGMwORcKwJVvLN6+zzJmYuoJq61n1jAM.Bc.I7BteOo5H96vqzTx9.oP9T6Kqh1zwgegnsBzXKVPGHo0j6zOIdSgRpUjfzMc4QhdPnfap49VIpiDj+XbPaL0Q7R3VQAd.TOj0BNGYwDEJcBwOPU3j1xUf+AdCGHi8bm5XSPl2uIFpYAbqLSdjXEyA1u4XirlPpdsmaZwolT+gBY.C4J6iBT4tPa1LoWEhdTUrPoL8rRYOKFAdtEUWcifSDyZhcPpNZ.aRdKJ4sjIlUrTMsfysQ4Xm6qYScD2TEwTCib0VFOjyCPYegbHCpIst57S+p.2IkbJrS1EL0sf.HpGuDa6jQDHx6mLBX28orSx2luZvKftLOsW9JiVC0hMv9rG4BE6GS03O49O1P0S+zVo0lbYXaUyg.SXY4r94WQSbG0ufRqny1ymG4IGjGBF+Ui3bnCQOaMxaBUl6hUCJhxvnkuBiZr5puZiqvne827MexjwnnO4+9sRFsj1W7FYviA0hMXYaMQLHjfajLnnsqigOfOq70CovPqLg7grlBfOlUVE0afUD8x0jdFwYxXDQw3ihQjEVONFQ7N8KGh6mHF42+A67pXKO0q5gnw2HJFi+8y+yiRwHoOE7y6OBECviiQwHKY6FxF6ctpYbrxbZpGNYca5wnhwmxa2WfjAss+lO5GnsxGZe2Kg6kMnsoxbhk01gFnDEilQGMeUy35iklMX3PrQ1VZDb0NbHyOK5ugJIUyrc3O6Mf1hy64hk0eLU+fPS9K6f2c+CmWH7QZGFXtht7YB5e++NgaiRRuMtCWQ6XO0TUIuvn8tRJ.eyjkTMWbWiqd0etRDxkZQO0zL4nJTvL42D15TuL0.QmveqKwAI9IGGP3TEDdP7dSamcte7Q.H3rM6aCnD7ry1k1oa1oCf.K4FCAextdZFWbeB1hyb5KJ2wLMhv5ZqtdEV6G9jGs8V60Y6JUNY253kOtZynZNl8Zrm3+U1bmlOi9EO82U835v2OuRkJHznksqbsx12vFWcZ2XsociqMsa7gS6FWeZ23it9MJZ5VbIshPIPV3l6pJruPRtTQig+eyuu6k.

[ustk]

@Oli-Ullmann Nice, I didn't see we could connect the macro knob to the MacroValue parameterId...

However when moving the real macro knob (from the Macro Control panel) and if the CUTOFF slider is a pluginParameter then it move accordingly so something still feels wrong here...

I feel more comfortable with my solution of making a modulator that mimics the macro behaviour. Perhaps in some cases it might be limited but for now it seems to fit my project just fine, so I don't have any reason to use the stock macro system anymore unless somebody shows me if I am missing the obvious