Click and pop sounds
-
Hello everyone :-)
If I have a very simple setup consisting of a waveform generator within a synthesizer group with an AHDSR envelope and set the attack to 0ms and the release to 1ms, I get a click/pop sound at the beginning and at the end when I press a note.
Is there a way to prevent this?
Here is a snippet:
HiseSnippet 1161.3oc4XssaaaCFVJILsI8LPG5s5hcQ5PwfOjz3gcwRhOjXz3Xinz1cWAC0uiIhDo.IUVMF1y15ivdD1ivdC1HkThohMbb7RaZ17EF5+D4G+OweodBNAjRtvwc0iFFCNtOD4OjoFTe.lxbZ2vw8ont908pue65uwqQyNcc1YXLVJg.GW2E20nk6JK4j96u9ocvgXFAFwxw4cbJA1mFQUi31aq2PCCagCfinQVZu9VsIbVcdHOQinEQkbhwjSwm.GfMps.xYOrbfi62gpBAUpUCuw5UqRp8C0HaRv0.R4i2rTEb+fp0ffiCVei0wNtK2Lfp3BeEVAR8htCOXn+.9uvx1f2QkziCACQYGe8Nmw1o9.ZXPuycORGGWTuQNqEybVOG0gFPufusSyHvajE1NM2ElFjJeMfjqEjVJCROC4SDzX0HIF77.TalBD8w5XiMTxz0w8Sn5bsBL02GgOEZIzDWXvZutToW4o+6k+X+DFQQ4LON6.tB5xV6kq9qqtxp+1pdWVT+9STlYaD7vPPLQwlzAwzLbMVRzwf3UdmgCSfKTTe7K5SWd17ojrSskhbVaFU0MFxoawCCL9JyyiGAbxca5mda6FXE1DTx4o0KFDJpANtMfyzkAYgnUPM.4oJdrtPXr3mNygGjDhUESmLEZ4Bz9iBwPSfhIopg1EhWibrRSMGaVg3yP8nJxfIiwEl.F0dpOGXLux7Qnl86CD0H.tDp0OOukgy91+jBcQ2UvShS28mmw.jTIH7R4W9lnSZ7L2IsICqOMs5Xuh0wBAEDsYAvGs17e+h36XRdKiJ4LdJT1NhmvT1fNWZCPkvJ.8bA9wB.GXagA89fFpAoKorPN7hECPKMa0zEKUrzeBMPu2sPO8al5sawVBEt1IOg+dns2qg+g4sBRe1qI6LHT2CrXhdGcdP7.NiRrSPNDTB5Im.BaDOwiw1Jkdlf5IhyJjg0.H3giwMS4w4rOnglM68zs4GQ+saktbWv3Shs7SjpBknFLGBXIXCtlDtNj.yoa+ZL.xzRMdDJ6P5k1R3ZmWrzrkWbEWLNiX8wmi0rHxW2f8gnzzh6B90mfxSXuS3XeLJuV5tfqcpS5r3+alz4pJTLi.3ok8U3rp5oyRGD4VDduHCdO.8d7YP5ngoH6aRo6yEQd6BLPXv8zlS7Ot4mSrKQogvQBLSFyk5KusVYeHhdDmAxBbujEUlnEUJdYsI6n73rJnkwUzR6JJaGMNmokl2eqdXVgESSWXk5P+nMY1nvYic1URzNFie1dW5kDJg2SCTCrV2+zhcEa16gEA5XXgAZt7vqy+09K+4ZF0uncM+2Ou5csl7233c9a3+ENRqK27tyDoeAR2BnhWZ3161OdeHOQQYmzAqeeHcSKzAIQ95dyDPiXFCB0aDxcAy6tmQWxPm0okEjR725e4BKancyEV9bg+mYOhvDA+CjruLnoU48S4n8srzuW7JnNFZuxNoesP6fWjtM4GHjhK0XFVYdMr57Z35yqgaLuF9540vMmWCqc0FZtEa6DEOJqVTeCduloedUW2rKuSKKc9GfvCV3U
Thanks a lot
Oli -
@Oli-Ullmann said in Click and pop sounds:
Is there a way to prevent this?
Longer attack/release time
-
The synth group randomizes the phase so that would create a click at the beginning. the release time is too short so that's the second click.
I need to check but I thought the synthgroup only randomizes the start offset with unisono values > 1 though.
-
@Christoph-Hart
In fact, I also hear a click when I load only a waveform generator. The click at the end disappears with a longer release.With a very short attack, it almost sounds like a sinewave basedrum.
Here is the snippet without the synthesizer group:
HiseSnippet 1042.3oc4XssaaaCFlJ1rsw8LPG5s5hcQ5PwfOkFWzKlS7gFiFGaDk0t6JXn9cLQjHEjn7lwVe25iPeD1ivdC1HkbhISbcMLV6Rv7EF9+D4G+Owe5gwBJjjHhQNkNdZDfbtG1aJWNt0XBii50F47H7.uVtsNnWq231tS+An8lFQRR.ejiSgWq0xYyhnrO+0OsGIfvovbVHzaELJb.KjImycXy2vBB5R7giYgFZWuYOpf2RDHRUHp.tLJhPOibJbHQq1FXz9jjwHme.WC7q1nAY650pQa7xFzcnjF.sxI6TtJYjesFf+I902tNA4bqN9LoH1SRjPBxo3dB+odiE+JOeCdKKgcR.nIpf7T6bN6th.e8QTyE0ZLKve34tpDDxAObtiqPti6I39Le1E7McfZAtysvzA5rgM7JXAuJlvqrA7V.jbLfTwbH8XrGMlEImKQim6h6wkP7HhJNYBkbcQNeD2RnTfK+wPxYP2XEwEFr0KJW94tpud1qFkxoRlf6J3GJjv.9VOqzuWZyRenj6kEMZzBko2lXQP.DuPw5Ti3kY3V7zvSf3m6NgDjBWnn53a6SwedepYHmlepMTTv6wYxAQ.+ykHfl4pT+5m60lHI5.wLdJ8hfXISCAm1vDUYPdXYSbaH4LoHRUHbkXlJaQ3mFPj1oP5BsYBT9.q3lN3vSXxolEhWNup3pkWs7z9UEtOFOjIoiWLd2XA3U409Zi2YUo2G2YzHfJmC1h3t+xRKI+WGJOMGJ2E+NxDHqaaFP9tL5Qh3P2WCbHV6SqrjtseZU61FsxcaGPkJHbbLgmDIRfJlqrGDxNVvgDKtWxhpKzBKtsAYJ2doyYYok1UzU4JpXlTeNSCMuSygDt0honsVo9reyjrCmnBddf5j6OHgpbLZ+r4tLLMHAdGyWN1Xc+SC1UMYuOI1WECoVIyEV4LHyFP103F5uft825q0EPeSaTbMoul0cmOLGu2Fu69s8NZV+rre61gOABTM0sqJ6K3hnwBNyJG3HPFyN8TvJ0ZgGockR0PNsRim.1EETxzqvMW4qx4.PAMS16qNwyo+9lYK2EL9XbSuzDoU+DMlC.Rx78y8OZ1gJTgGXYgfBqV18WXJpkklbeb9gzMq+00669dv4XMOhb8Fr2CmkVbSvu9P7rD1aDN1GfmUKcSv0tzw0J7+9w0V9EXpwKbuwLX9SwpQdp5lEtc+uOdejHUx3m1mntpTMjF9vzPO0rnTPgXNGBzucyYC8qrxoKqoymrj6mQ72pOyDVQS6LSXkyE9MYOBIzXw6o4uJUew1cx3nN27r+2hMw80ztUPYuT0zwFplL68Tp8RcECqttFVacMr95Z31qqguXcMbm00vFeYC0CNuapTDlWmndMwvNYOy2wI+gDYkLn+AhWrBrB
-
@Oli-Ullmann nope, that looks exactly like what you'd expect without any attack time:
As you can see it starts from zero, but there's a discontinuity in the first derivative which you perceive as click.
-
@Christoph-Hart
All right. Thanks for the explanation! :-) -
O Oli Ullmann has marked this topic as solved