Linkwitz Riley Filter Crossover Issue
-
Merry Christmas to everyone!
Scriptnode Linkwitz Riley Filter doesn't make the crossover (band split) correctly. I used All pass to compensate the phase delay, but you can hear the phase issue while tweaking the "Low Split" knob.
Any ideas?
HiseSnippet 1548.3oc6ZEyjaSDEdk8oiyWRf.jLgRMglKyDtwxIAHCE14NaG7Pbh4zkKoKydRqs2wR6JjVeWbxPWFF5nlT.sPCTQAcohJxLYl7G.JnBJNZn.Jf2p09jjsycFSRNRhUk22tuUeu2aee6p84FAbaRXHO.oka8d9Dj1g0s5wDsWsMlxP0JizdY853PAIvPIZkd93vPhCRSK6EkBzxMGJ5YmhqfcwLaRrHDZCN0lbIpGUDKsQoOf55VE6PVm5kXzmsTMaNaUtKuKfmr54Q9X6N3VjKikCKiNRa9JNTAOvRfEjPj1bqvc5Y0luMSM9MngzMcIxFlHKXhThqxccjHVJEsZapqSiA1cHBoo2H1KjU4ENldcpCcW4wdiiF0gQrFI8GZY1K3YlDd4mX3gRft4TnC.A2oqKVjFYxvQ+Nn7zQpZLAgERE8RFtNPg6qp2fJraOd7lYL3EBTOowa+f+QzqzrIwVDC14zqd8m7QZMsQ8cKpaYGP8Ev6WBjC2uoQ0qalBPJwHsuVuBqEkQV1Nf.Pqbn+kIhs4AcV5jNg9m7TFu2QVrYWlszia3GP7wAj04Mbw8VJD646RVCz5zFa5xs6XQuE4TKd6Eys3GunQBkhv3JxQrjcaLiQbCGcXxDYlHf6tDqq2ljfSarE1sa77MRtb1GsKLYt7Xhfqw6JnrV0wh.5Mgz4K20yBnPrIq1GcfLsLHopQsyKaKWPYQXNQM9a3oemlx1Z86zbPmHowPXBPde+YT7p+ugeICN55fKVJk6.vdgpXav750.KZKWtCTaBX8DIXY6cWWMuTCSD.3gg5k.uaJwZYkS6.xQE9Wk64IAkjZr+uuF0Q95z0NMLB0Bj0f3pjnsdXRpV07orBEdk.5kzC8cAt5GI1Uc+jBvxveCb.P2Ca3HmiLwvLSJXp7g6iK9fwuBqM8IABpD0nwg9WQ2kx5rMUbq.pKoWZq3D5MotRqe4zC5+A1RLW853fVDQD6YbzRtQ5fVvrTisEnohcpNksgL6O4jWGeyzx9zGV5R7sIACcZgyV5p99CKEFqkf3KYnjxt6mKe99hVcHaq7lRly7KWnv4Oe9yEkpcH8pAjOpKgY2Cs668tY9teg7W2oDZR.9YhddXwj.+9+n74MGB3CFYZfOXr6GvyM2e9Ee0ebxe+AEk3Nq9GhFx2sSQzj6nKbuQbznBi0QW3diwQCic+w6.XonzhNU3PuwjqT1WHCqzFAx6TbbPFgFGj2oXRHe6i8MW7mu0cFBx+cuurwqW9gEUKMr73bQaXOjXbOPs+i3FUZxwMJkqdWaYOb00kjJi5pSv0bzzbMElQ1LirYFYyLxlGWjMkRkTlj4YA0YzLeF5PZZOZhSyYDmyHNmQbNi37wDwYxUGijgpkvZlWY6.9Lrh916IJKszmk.k5PNlIJIBkRNSLjZ0Dd9gMJoosJGHoht.GINxF2DocXIqUMmQ+70cAqryjIvf1QAhnz7ZN.ml7B8th+t2rEQnfvAMITt491e8D+1m3c+hUtoe.ILLxfApXzXc.ibl5Wz8.lOW6ARs6Z5j1j8b0ZkwBrL6s+cElnWMsxjsn1DkUmSuLIrif6m5xmOtpyCoeM7VjnZvDsi3wiZ2jG3YbQBbpI4snatGUg4ASZUX7m3pvbEaA.g0CvrPedHwL4LOTeER1WYhnKK8vUhRMJo4UELuDiagRCDVHovFXVpICZmZlpKu82AM+ohUX3McIVDvZbtRnMXr3gnmaz0MjDcNKyjJFKtPRwuONvAhK1oJIQ1ItN.+KJH07yJH09URf76YIARUIkbCvnEUVfiJ.QiKjYFgwWCREah65JFHMcpUcNi62lynoB5qQDAzVsHo2pebFzEDBrcmXIGqzZDWBNLMKF7wP3fnCILc9ByI2WrWwq2PWAWCIefwyGERL6KjERbxyPAJymchzmPGnwKXDEtMN3i2OMJ63Si2gG1NfeCaU0ZkDFKDIAraVz+6hb50ksMLQaoN.l7qGxi7fsctgssbM8aA9mwqSgoPmyLE5b1oPmyME571SgNuyTny6tm5H2w+BcEbO05ePPiJQG9TSScnmnTAz+PFxeHT -
Any ideas or fixes please? I saw some examples in the forum but none of them is working properly.
Can we make a proper band split (without phase problem) with Hise? @Christoph-Hart
-
@Fortune IIRC Christoph said the Linwkitz Riley isn't ideal for modulating/tweaking. I've been using One-Pole for stuff like that, but you might have better luck with one of the other types.
-
@iamlamprey said in Linkwitz Riley Filter Crossover Issue:
@Fortune IIRC Christoph said the Linwkitz Riley isn't ideal for modulating/tweaking. I've been using One-Pole for stuff like that, but you might have better luck with one of the other types.
Have you checked the one pole style splitter in Plugin Dostor? I tried all ways but all of the filters in Hise is giving frequency bump (and phase issue) on crossover points.
I guess the proper splitter can't be done in Hise for now :(
-
@Fortune Yeh I assume it'll be tricky getting a perfect crossover with the ability to modulate it. You might have to implement your own for this
-
Hey @Fortune @iamlamprey @Christoph-Hart any updates on this? I'm doing a project with crossover bands too and the phase issue with HISE filters makes it impossible to finish ;-)
-
@tomekslesicki I'm afraid that working crossover bands are not available in Hise yet.
Scriptnode Linkwitz Riley Filter has a phase issue and not working properly. -
Good to know, thank you!
