Collaborative project!

lalalandsynth

@ustk I will also test on the mac later today

d.healey

I couldn't see anything on vi-control so I posted it to the freebies thread there.

hisefilo

@d-healey cool mate. didn't find the time. thanks for that.

I'm so happy with results. so much talent here. not just us 4 but many others.

ustk

@lalalandsynth Ok so after performing some tests I've been able to reproduce the bug in reaper on Windows.
Although reaper on macOS works as expected, like the other DAWs...

I am currently trying to figure out what it can be but, there's a big chance we can't do anything as it certainly comes from scriptnode itself.
I'm trying to narrow down the issue so maybe @Christoph-Hart could fix it before v3...?

Can you please tell me if it happens or not within other DAWs?

lalalandsynth

@ustk I dont have any other daws here , but I can test in reaper on mac to verify your test.

ustk

@lalalandsynth I'm pretty sure it's fine on macOS
Maybe someone else can test for us with another DAW on windows?
My bootcamp partition is too small to install anything else, I must extend it...

alepan

Will test it on new UA Luna today

alepan

Ok, trying it now on Luna (so AudioUnit format). I can hear lots of clicks and pops at almost every note I play and some occasional complete muting of the instrument. But I think this is a Luna-related issue, as in MainStage 3 the instrument behaves fine, sounds good and produces no clicks whatsoever.
I will try it on ProTools in the afternoon.

ustk

@alepan Thanks for the feedback ;)
Tested successfully in PT (made my own AAX)

musictop

Windows / Tracktion Waveform 11 / no problems, no issues - works fine. Already using it in a project!

musictop 6 minutes ago

Windows / Cakewalk Bandlab / no problems, no issues - works fine.

lalalandsynth

I dont get it guys , I have the same issue on the mac .

Note burst , with the rotary on . ( Maybe note burst is the wrong word , some kind of chirpy sound)
So bad in my opinion that i could not use it , very annoying for the ears when stopping starting , when editing.
Try with this midi file.
P10_70 - P10_70-glued render 001.mid

Also, there is a clear difference between placing the start cursor on the start of a chord and placing it before and letting it play to the cursor.

It does change depending on how close you are to the start of the file.
https://youtu.be/ehsw9WdzhYM

d.healey

Need more details to make accurate comparisons

DAW
DAW version
OS
OS version
Sound card / Audio interface
Audio Driver
Bit depth
Sample rate

lalalandsynth

PC
Reaper.
Version 5.978/x64
Win 10.
Motu Traveler.
24 bit
44.1khz

ALSO , tested on the latest Reaper version 6.08/x64 .

MAC.
Reaper
Version 5.979/64
Mac OS Mojave 10.14.5
Inbuilt sound card Mac mini.
24bit
44.1Khz.

Downloading ableton Demo for mac to test.

EDIT: does not seem to happen in Ableton on Mac.
Doing some further testing in Reaper PC

alepan

@ustk You're welcome mate :)

dejans

Works great here in Cubase 10 Pro. Thanks guys! Btw. some people seem to have problems with Hise builds in Reaper, not the Collab3 but other instruments built in Hise, some synths from Beatskillz I think. So it could be platform wise, something messing with the Reaper in Hise, I dunno, this is just a theory. This is a comment from their youtube promo of a synth/rompler built with Hise,


Leo Krechmer
1 week ago
Hope it wont crush reaper like any other plugins of them...

Lindon

@dejans I think this comment is pointing at Beatskillz older product set - built in Maize, only their latest product (RetroVolt) is built in HISE - and it was rigorously tested in HISE on Reaper...