Snex_node Needs to be wrapped into a compileable DSP Network

[Christoph Hart]

Can you send me the project (just the DspNetworks subfolder)? It seems that the order of includes doesn‘t detect the inclusion of test1 in your main network.

[Matt_SF]

This post is deleted!

[Matt_SF]

@Christoph-Hart Here's the folder. (Don't mind the Math.expr equation, I was just messing around :beaming_face_with_smiling_eyes: )
DspNetworks.zip

[Brian]

Thank you @Christoph-Hart & @Matt_SF ! ( Just waking up here on North American time ). I'll be on standby to download and test the fixes, super excited to see this work and try some crazy DSP experiments :)

[Christoph Hart]

@Matt_SF Thanks for the example. It also doesn't work here for a few reasons, some are trivial, some are a bit harder to fix. BTW, I noticed you're using the stk.DelayA node, this is deprecated (I removed the entire stk module). Use the jdsp.jdelay node for a interpolating delay line instead.

[Matt_SF]

@Christoph-Hart Noted thanks ! Yes this was not meant to be anything, I was just testing something.

[Christoph Hart]

@Matt_SF said in Snex_node Needs to be wrapped into a compileable DSP Network:

Yes this was not meant to be anything, I was just testing something.

Yeah, it would require some Steve Jobs level marketing to monetize this :)

[ustk]

@Christoph-Hart said in Snex_node Needs to be wrapped into a compileable DSP Network:

I noticed you're using the stk.DelayA node, this is deprecated (I removed the entire stk module). Use the jdsp.jdelay node for a interpolating delay line instead.

But jdelay isn't meant to be modulated like DelayA was, right?

[Christoph Hart]

sure, just don't modulate the limit. The core.fix_delay is not the most suitable candidate for modulation as it fades between two delay buffers to avoid pitch shifting, but that's what you want for all chorus, phaser, etc effects.

[ustk]

@Christoph-Hart ok so I have to test again, because what I just tried gave me nothing but artifacts and glitches…

[Christoph Hart]

Well it‘s the delay class from JUCE which is used in their chorus and phaser implementations so it‘s supposed to work...

[ustk]

@Christoph-Hart Unless I'm doing it wrong:

HiseSnippet 1447.3oc6X8zaaTDEeVaOlXmTTAZEbbUEGRkJQ1lxej3PbSbbIh5Vq3Pa4TY5tSrG75YV1cbZLHNwG.NCm3C.GPb.ItwAthDR7EfSHN1uAva1Yc1Yh2XmXQaEU3KIy6Mu27ad+adusajviFGKhPNU1eRHE4rFt2Dtbv1CHLNZ2VHmWD2gDKoQtZRaMIjDGS8QNNEuohfSkRnjeOdysHADtGMiDBcWAyidK1HlLiZ2le.KHnMwmtOajwtudyc8D7sEAhw.dJhqgBIdCI8o2ln1VALxo7N9LoHpmjHowHmRaI7mzaf3Qb89uKKl8v.pZQcTOPQZxsEA9JDq9ez1CXA9cmduiQHGb2LqPQsU3R3NLe1wzyrFWLggalDl1CmByCd0MgWsbgW8bfGx.ckznC.gveb.QZiLk6HkASX6o1kKo7Xlbho65YJbeIbWlzaP93sPN3EbTOowapy+B3cN3.pmLCrkvsu+x5oOGAhNyZ6ph64EwBkv4q.xZoKcae+5V.RSF47c3c38Yb5FdQT.ZshCuMU9HQzv0uhOMfLAr2W4puW0CFy8TFc2vHZHIhtunKvb8Xxnv.5dffWy8gABug8XeF8pU+7pUp9EUcMDJAlao1w5dCHbNMHd1soxk4xHQv57widHM5ZtGRBFmouYRmKd1rh43D2SLVx386PjQrifL5aOdTOnJhGc6TzAzbJfThlrtlZsJlpGk6mr3ugeoLqqV6jxr9TlH0kgxk.8TSZhKK8+g+S4ephmZkUrD9Jr2l3A2wIcIxApvdnDmDhqnQa3cb7kgX1QYJUnOFstTa9EvwgAP8zSUuZ14qnhVJRifE.v7UTAshJog+HgeN55RF553c.tFSmhxNOWnVRG2Kh8fGMT0PlEuQzMLXuvCXagJJ+nVDIQYZaw.CFYxVigjdcZnEEkmk6SO533ftjH38HodukOdEvuCieWUDtYQqNjiNAsK1rmjFpxrLKFqtkkUEJonYzAx3PJadHeyWq98SaN6g75m7P9V095Mj9Hs0KkZyubzulbzqhaGQ+zwTt2Djo5KpvFZ9WxGmy4W6TujqkbRt6oJ5ilQSnyu87wad51yaBEVl+gT5rdH5LltCHwKvCctzX4jWsML4+h62G8W+vlHcvOVsmJ3XV+FPBjcj+KhGA+cio7VPX+zmdbJ.OyXFA6r7FCM4YMFFItkwgTxPafupNkMgwhRVKl0fv9jn9TYBjOIQ3bTm4tfLqf+jjZoYdDE0UwsTDS52bGNAdTIwTb1tteTyYxa93Wo0uuI5ewBI1KLLfPQ5.J4DE8VS650bdV4kyAwIOqrh9YkFK26JNVZJ0WZooK.TiC2HkkkVruyEN20RZ9UmhqVaIzywLiHmZ44yeHktTbVr5MFKEfqNMZclndnklE3EpuTdg4DZZs3C2cZreZyQPSYgzHIS0MmSK5gvve59Xq.Wp3gRQnUC2WVybU78HGRSl6LocnKmr9.QzH2aRAnpdVu9oM44O+m+1OdVm7L7LO44c7j.D1OhviCEwz5lZ9D7ZXxqEUNlaucMIqcotdsgqmw9Vo4ThMLI1kvsTFr1RScTs6lsTWaqGEtM92IqkHib5tiCho2i4KGXn2+vfbCSxuOIxG7KdVigUbol8wd5Ti8myfPk++IxWz.Q0l6.QViRVYJF6wTuWsC+PZ.jllfwWFxKOfLNPNkpcdVGAWDNPvYVQ.6Qgwr52mZEXk6E5FRIwaXFkK0bOJ7nUrUmp2BJGQhRZ8c4rE0O61h44udMrFttphCtOe7kTJ9bzWR4IQFJT+7+Nd5WEC0za3l3tce16ueZ7QWdZbFiHdQhG3o+VUpBFqjPAt27jO7bEbG0Z25nC0cwgw01nFZD7ryC77TwzuAXexWlFKgLu4RHy0WBYdqkPl2dIj4cVBYd24Ji5E+zViUw+.gt6jzIpiS1zcEQ+CjC2c6.

[Matt_SF]

@ustk @Christoph-Hart and I noticed the same glitches appears if you modulate the simple gain Delay parameter :

HiseSnippet 1079.3oc6X0rjaSDDdjsmTqKfTg7SAG0AtQQJKuKAxIbVu1KtvN1rZqDn3PpAo1VSEoYDRiVv23MfWMdD3NW3M.lQxRZjWgWGE1JYSgO3xc2yOeS+e6EQbGHNlGgL5d95P.Y79X60Lg2POBkglbBx313YjXADYlw530gj3XvEYXz9TECitcPoe9qu5XhOg4.krPnmwoNvTZ.UTxcwfug56Ol3BmSCzV8QCl3vYC497DIdZi6gBINujrBdJQsrVXjwsF4RE7HaAQ.wHiNGycWa6w+YV15eFMl9i9fhvBYKOnL1i49tJDq9MZnG02cQ96NFgLvKJ0BsyzB2GOi5RK3WpMtSp.yxcnqOLZsK3YoCud0BOqZfGRCccxPmDDb2DehnJxTliMBn7pVpILAvhoh05lq2nv8CwKnBGu5waqZvqzPcci2MF+O.OZ4RvQTB1N3weWSszuBNhstLV5hOimH.40mozTTT1JyYDQD8WrpBp1ulfpV8ylaL6Bk.5oIA1x.TGPpdXLvWdQXCkMZCcOEsxbYCL2ThVkBsTzFaDlRztTXeE8eK+nDVPrQ3g5BKHzsdGTj.iFD5CmVl.Kigohi0NRfgPm.9jbWte8O+16M34TWgW4J99A0jhaB6BHRrf6Sh11gcKCR68yfTimQm8NpR8jLuwjE3t3TU90EfeEh8LzP7syPLFOc77M4Vk+xr.+VWMHGGA+TBvbzXdv.UIuIkNbC9sAOmbArjGErIXuX6SgUxKRmy4PPHWVZ1Q2AyNfyEdxnypERu+fobd3HFQpFb0OjEdjXX9xkwfP+XFlDK3A4XIsRqs.BOgHHHie.+nidn7yxOU88iGJ+5v4+2PeoL5MO.o0d5vcuTKYgISYSeKODICwE9S2.P7cwooMu4jE5N3Ej2FRZ1nRs40D6sUASKcgVaIredc4+0Rss2Hr1RsOHSY9dXUNiz4ER0iO.mmCw7TfAQWNWY0Bt+99NwP3dOwvbGgDBmGQXwg7XvR+j2RV+pU9EIrpKOiUkUoddikOOKcegbl80S0KcnpbXR5JmzrTCbAYVtZaP9ZbmG6HerJcWkT2I9wPZbk149GZr6qy9qIQtaWrngsGVcpBs0WSV3a8+SRcU0w5s65X5sgzMGiY8uNR1moOWxIuwokjDeQN2pwYy3LdnGmQq3AbFHSrrZETwwp1GzSDB4n25cTbF3CxlGJY8IClRY.IRpmfFpKr1ecwtrWeLNCtlpjCluaLAb62gl.95HBUl+7lik9ivxb58MSM2lu4s2a0lAt11LZsqI52tMiJSzm1rvq++ZvUdG5sxf1UqLFWpUl.hSD+ExhshHtuJUyAobjZLV5e0XW7LEsoE5BheR5nf8dXOTfrf0KbbTQCelTyV+d52f8bXC1yQMXOedC1yiZvd9hFrmubm6Q0qvSRjSolE4HYrXT17oFEy4J6Y8e3jtzy.

[Christoph Hart]

Unless I'm doing it wrong:

Scriptnode 101: if modulating sounds bad, put it in a frame block (or fix8, fix16, whatever works).

[ustk]

@Christoph-Hart Of course... Silly me, I used an oversample chain....

[Matt_SF]

@Christoph-Hart said in Snex_node Needs to be wrapped into a compileable DSP Network:

Unless I'm doing it wrong:

Scriptnode 101: if modulating sounds bad, put it in a frame block (or fix8, fix16, whatever works).

Mmmhh, we agree that we are talking about putting the jdsp.delay node into a container.frame2_block or a container.fix8_block right ? Because it not working here, so I'm guessing I, now am doing it wrong

[ustk]

@Matt_SF Put the whole thing in it, not just the delay node ;)

[Christoph Hart]

This post is deleted!

[ustk]

@Christoph-Hart What is the main block size decision? (8-16-32..)
Is it the computing charge of the graph, like the more you have to compute, the larger the block should be?

[Christoph Hart]

Yes, at the end it's all about CPU usage, but be aware that these kind of applications are supposed to be compiled into a C++ node, so the performance difference between the different block sizes might not be so huge in the end.

However, if you don't hear artifacts with higher block sizes for the intended use cases, there's no reason to go lower, so the general rule of thumb would be "try the highest block size that doesn't sound bad".