Hanging notes ?

[lalalandsynth]

I just got a bug report for the Collab B3 where the user was having hanging notes in his project. He sent me his midi file and the problem was overlapping notes .

So a C1 played on top of a C1 , therefore the synth not getting a note off.
However this is not a problem for any of the other synths I tested.

Is this a known problem in HISE ?

EDIT: Tested with simple synth ( Waveform gen ) - HISE vst in Reaper and it hangs.

If someone could verify before I post a bug report.

moon untitled MIDI item render 002.mid

[d.healey]

@lalalandsynth said in Hanging notes ?:

simple synth

What's this?

[lalalandsynth]

@d-healey just running a waveform Gen in VSt version in Reaper.

[d.healey]

No problem here in Qtractor. This is the snippet I'm using for testing with the MIDI file you provided.

HiseSnippet 1168.3oc4W0raabCDlqkYPjRLZSgKP6sEA8fCfqwtpN9m1CQ1VRtFw+HX43zaAz6RIQXJxE6x0NBA4ReU5KPeD789RzGfdnuAtCWtxK2DYWAA3fhTcR7alg7algyLb6DKCnIIxXjS0SFEQQNOF2cjPMXmADl.sWSjyCvJZhBs8nHRRBMD43TYWsLmpyix982uXaBmHBnEPHzoRV.ce1Plp.sSiWx371jP5IrgVZuZi8BjhcjbYJviJXOTDI3bRe5gDsZygARzJjojwcUDfLHm42VFNp6.4kBi9mxRXmwo5E9ntvFYfaK4gZFqQQ6LfwC6L1eSPHGbmBuuhw6WDe.KjcCdQT3KyD3VXgc7vYt6hd91zya5omiE8l2Pumf6FDyhTERzb6Q38DJZbOBjBrokQWjyU3cjfBB0JCImSaGCKtwfkVyyaY2m648repWpHPwjBWo3PohdjXomU6c0pV680b+PQ85MQY5iIVx4z3IJVm0iuKCWRjN7LZ7xtWP3ozaTDb+xwW7sGesS+AFu1RQoXOAScTDUbaQcTdnB92q1qIQQzIhbLPuHZrhoofSS5EvMbSZoJtIM4bkLJS2gQRgdGbdrJ+NkIQzlKIJln+ILfpLHC8EXaHezasKfFUrXTibBXNsZ3WRGcljDGhNq+3plpOHLL7Zs1LEcXA50We82VFsdNblxJ5aUEJ+GWYPy7643N32sPMW2mBG2qYgpAO8Gc8WcEuky.axRh3jQGEnHWPOLKuAx6Q3ITiB6KuDLDv1zr9mYlk90W2.rSZhRNb2XRz.VPRYiaR6QR4pshhnjXcuEPrJNMW51bn+.raGCAOIHwak01L62Fa3s9ldq6aT6DY+9b5AxPZ4MWWICU1BAkq4iA7UIzSoAvkLKBUbhfz1bhpqZD+C2rNsFmN9HAv80XUwIU+FAsDgVDXsEp8dzk5H7M47q90FCnr9CJ5dd0wMPebCAnsjLLEXV4dU5Fz4BfBrRMEzU9hDlZjcC76kFXSKceBtCSELXx7ctIvWnj79lu4iCV.2pWO3VQAYmG29Wt+68aSkEMT4Q3WCEZYylyHxWmstmLdn6tTAMVGS8u0oz+0u+aS6T5nodJso1+Dn9LIRl.Mvr14OPVcaYMopTQY0MPkzR6dsA2yRuG1XLXcavNDQoMCVWZmNfY0Y8OeQKAARHcof2DdTR.3r5Xmc4PmTnJNqkmusgEv0sgcpL02.9r4wIe5ZEUY5n6+x6mpNlicYCi3zVhKnbXXdFG+Jb9zlwn0KwxCjBYz.ofEXem5XpJl0uOsz8lI5PaoTvzpBjEabLkSIIVkVeWi8YBXPmdT0LFK7m9Xwcku9Frgtt5Ze2OOFgT4+8iPt6JTn83+AxzGKS0uD9.BTWAsqwvSJ6BSZBn4OTR+rem4zOP2r1SuVSntTQX1B8aZyE5qW6jKzervOImwPRPr7MAlOnQW58vLDvuEYeMaU7A50t9nrOxArC6shGZHz.+MAA5aGeODelrM0mAa9gYvlUmAad9LXyZyfMqOC1rwcZid14VovmhXt+C.cZk8EPNNlmJjUJf9G.zoKhdB

Have you tried a different DAW?

[lalalandsynth]

@d-healey Testing in Live ...sec.

EDIT: Does not happen in Live.
In Reaper however HISE seems to be the only VST that hangs of all the ones I tested and I tested a lot of synths. ?

Hard to tell a user that its a Reaper problem when its specific to your plugin.

[d.healey]

Not just your plugin

https://forum.cockos.com/showthread.php?t=183737&highlight=hanging+notes
https://forum.cockos.com/showthread.php?t=243006&highlight=hanging+notes
https://forum.cockos.com/showthread.php?t=234740&highlight=hanging+notes
https://forum.cockos.com/showthread.php?t=235278&highlight=hanging+notes
https://forum.cockos.com/showthread.php?t=236845&highlight=hanging+notes
https://www.reddit.com/r/Reaper/comments/58crf3/hanging_midi_notes_latest_version/
https://www.soundonsound.com/forum/viewtopic.php?f=16&t=71696&p=665656&hilit=
https://forum.cockos.com/showthread.php?t=243006&highlight=hanging+notes
https://forum.cockos.com/showthread.php?t=183737&highlight=hanging+notes
https://forum.cockos.com/showthread.php?t=237297&highlight=hanging+notes

[lalalandsynth]

@d-healey Lol, apparently not ! heheh
That is "good news"

[Christoph Hart]

Ah yes the blame game. I love it especially if the opponent is Apple