Using external Text Editor
-
I strongly agree that there should be a little better support for external editors. Similar to @Simon and @oskarsh I have really fought the built in editor when it comes to just getting code written. I seem to gravitate back to the built in when debugging and working in UI.
The auto-autocomplete is also extremely unreliable for me. It feels like it stops working completely pretty often.
Honestly, being able to avoid overwrite-on-compile and watching for script changes / auto compile would be enough for me. The regular JS syntax highlighting in Sublime, Atom, VS Code are all much better for me but could easily be community addressed if someone wanted something more robust.
-
@d-healey I posted that comment because (in my memory anyway) I typed for and nothing happened, which led me to believe it doesn't appear for "for". The delay in autocomplete makes me much less likely to use it, while I use the instant popup in Sublime all the time.
How you fold code is of course user preference. I would quite like to be able to fold each control declaration along with its settings, callback assignment, and callback function, so when I'm looking for a control I can get an overview of all of them, and jump straight to the one I need without ctrl + f or the re-contextualization of bookmarks.
-
@Simon said in Using external Text Editor:
I can get an overview of all of them, and jump straight to the one I need without ctrl + f or the re-contextualization of bookmarks.
Yeah this is what I use bookmarks for, middle click and there's a list of all components.
-
@oskarsh Be aware that there are issues with using an external text editor—namely, that HISE will sometimes overwrite your original file. Usually, this happens when HISE opens the same file in HISE, like if you click on an error report in the Console. But sometimes it just happens. My workaround its to use an external editor that tells me when a file that it has open was overwritten by HISE, and gives me the option to reject HISE's changes, or keep my own. (Though HISE hasn't actually made any changes; it's simply overwritten my last changes in the external editor, though it's more nuanced than that, which is another of saying I'm too lazy to be more specific.) There was a bug about this which was fixed a while back, which improved the situation a lot. But problems remain, so be careful so you don't lose any code. I know @Christoph-Hart has put a lot of work into HISE's built-in editor, and after two years, I'm still finding about cool stuff in it that I wasn't aware of. If do decide to go with an external editor, I can send you my list of HISE Script keywords for your editor. (If you're using BBEdit, I went so far as creating a HISE Script language module.)
-
@clevername27 Yes I am aware that HISE will overwrite the changes. I am suggesting a button or just a function that we can bind to a shortcut "reload and compile" which basically uses the file on Disc and not from the memory.
I believe this should be easy to implement since we already have Load XML which basically does the same, reload all scripts, xml and compile them.
If we could only get a shortcut or button for this functionality...I think the HISE editor is great for what it is but it will always lack against other editors which main job is to edit text. I am a big fan of removing dependencies and having a editor which I can style, use plugins (heck even VIM bindings) and have a very reliable and fast editing experience would be my biggest Christmas wish.
Many IDE's have moved away from this baked in editor style approach, just less dependencies and maintenance.
@Christoph-Hart can you play Santa and look into this? Mainly just a "reload and compile" function that we can bind to a shortcut?
helping you with HISE - hit me up :)
developer for hire -
@oskarsh I love your idea.
-
@oskarsh said in Using external Text Editor:
Mainly just a "reload and compile" function that we can bind to a shortcut?
I think a file watcher would be better, no need to hit a button manually. Just save the external file and the changes will be there in HISE.
Libre Wave - Freedom respecting instruments and effects
My Patreon - HISE tutorials
YouTube Channel - Public HISE tutorials -
@d-healey I love that idea, too.
-
-
@d-healey you are right!
I am trying to get my Christmas Presents in time tho. Not sure Christoph has the prime delivery for a file watcher :D
So a button would do for the beginning. A file watcher would be the better solution but more work to get it right.
This one is the industry standard btw:
https://facebook.github.io/watchman/ -
For those who might have missed it, a code template has been introduced recently:
https://docs.hise.audio/glossary/code_snippets.html
https://forum.hise.audio/topic/10434/new-feature-code-templates?_=1734545220760
Can't help pressing F5 in the forum...
-
@ustk I completely forgot about that already!
-
@ustk thanks for the reminder!
