MIDI Learn improvement

[ustk]

Currently, when we enable midi learn from right-click -> Learn MIDI CC, we can actually learn multiple CCs (the last one isn't replaced as it is reflected in the MIDI learn panel).

In the dropdown, only the last one is showing, but all previous CCs are still functional until you remove the last CC. Then they all disappear at once.

So something is off. Should we able to only learn/assign ONLY one CC, or should we keep the multi-CC capability and reflect this in the dropdown menu as well?

To me, there's no point in having multiple CCs for one slider, because you get jumping values as soon as you touch a different controller... But, that's just me...

I am in the middle of making a PR for this, so I'd need your opinion guys

SOLUTIONS:

1. Keep only one:

• Easy, just replace the last attributed CC with the new one

2. Keep multiple:

• I would then:
  -> Tick them all in the Assign MIDI CC sub-menu
  -> Expose all "Remove CC#"
  -> Add a "Remove All CC"

[David Healey]

@ustk said in MIDI Learn improvement:

Easy, just replace the last attributed CC with the new one

I would go with this.

[ustk]

@David-Healey yup me too, I will just hold this a wee bit if somebody sees it differently

[Lindon]

@ustk Im all on board with the replace approach too...

[dannytaurus]

@ustk +1 for 'replace last'

[ustk]

4 over 4, that's enough stats for me