applyMask behaves differently at different UI scales

ulrik

@Fergler Yes I can see the problem here as well.
I made a gif of what is happening.

The path (p1) is used as a mask (the black rounded rectangle) , I also draw the same path with

g.drawPath(p1, obj.area, 4);

the white rounded rectangle

As you can see, the mask is not following the scaling but the same path alone does.

@Christoph-Hart this looks like a bug.

HiseSnippet 939.3ocsV8taaaCDmzIpX1scnAXO.B4SJ.BtVoo+AXXnoIwtvnwoFQYECnHnflh1lyTjBTzISsneauW6YouA8MX6nnUrbi65fwp9frNd+ti+ti2czC0JJKOWoQ3lWTjwP364EWHMSOdJgKQ8OAguuWNkH3xIYDyTzQEYj7bVBBi25kVH3laiJe97yOhHHRJa4RHzaTbJ6TdJ2rb0gG9JtPzijvtfmVC8AG1mpjGqDp4.c1xqCJiPmQlvNiXg0vCguS2DtQoiMDCKGg29HURQ7T00RG92vy4iDLqPDJFbja4dJQhkw1UQGOkKRFVE14HvKCWlD1xkD9IuA7D9MquLY7fRE9Ksnd9.2XU5s0JzKpN85TidqgR3ZTZaGk1wKlp4YlkZr74td8kFldLAR60ohCKpwe0v6XEfPZZmRlw5oAgarH3Ic5D5Cu16maAY9biufL1+W76Jmvkr1TMChiWJTiHBm+NUol8BYROFSD.1.naqYS34f+5MWRMbkLX2DM45yUFhtHVvSX5cC8GWobRnuZzuum+GZ0p4j14Li6zNv8SN3sDvufpwPEx4LpI.f2l.DwtbqlWQz9YQ.EqBJGGGBUlANDSZOBXj7TRASGXzyY1kyhZSRRNWMWB0AV2RjSDrf2V47214xva9Np126e4C2eozi.oKC8i533HIKSTLfjOKHKpLtJQE5uXWsPXxDGSpH2sC4qmxMLmCsYtxPw5uMjbGX24OZe4NQyKOCpkwfDwqjpQA6dAK2raXmPazTc.4qjmoLrWKC1q0G.F+wV9eopwiWqNq60JgvFqqQssSW+uYXfbd5HlNz+Jh.ReU.gx+U6o7958T0a4otnsFPkrujadcFS90FDfVjhr8eKXE.0T188iK59bkzHNzjcGOaFDUx25i7P+Z+SHFRkW.GBaRFSa3V9iOgcELRz0S2z6DV9LiJqDaZlRZ2dr22ZO+C.C1tUEUe.sfYw72WQjC+z6+ymit8PDX7kJYtfXVcllcP9BEvgxJCRrCKj4bSQ8A8+uMn6+JE2waH2PmtdN1XMbDx9eO33hqGtuW2wigwHKI31d89suO2EffwVF312ADilaO3OadZLL4fxfcWJYBaSAtgs70I2oplHFl9TJ72vyBkQVY7BkQUJQoDpV8Npqn2dAzOTtBvIY4cuM8FXk8itc4dJbe36nzUc0sLb+M0vGsoFdvlZ3i2TCexlZ3S2TCe121P6eW4EyMpTWaCBMXX2xwSXbWIAp.KqVQ+CffzY8m

Fergler

I should mention this also applies to the plugin preview window if you changed zoom scale - but I have not tested a built plugin yet.

Goodflow

This issue is still present on the latest develop build. I'm getting inconsistent results when testing across platforms.

OSX - scaling bug in plugin preview, but compiled plugin has no issues

WIN - scaling bug in plugin preview and compiled plugin

Added a UI zoom tile to the prior snippet for convenience:

HiseSnippet 1196.3ocsVstaaaCElxILq1ccqEXO.B4WJ.FdVtYa.aXnIwWxBpcrQbZ1.BB5nkns4BEofDUxbCBv9wvds1yxdC1aP2ghRwRINaMAq5GRjma76bz4BGEI8nwwxHjU0iWDRQVeJd7BgZd64Dl.cPGj0yvwdDNSLKjnli1aQHINl5irrVaesHVUWGk972uZOBmH7nKIgPmHYdz9r.lZI0Q67ZFm2i3SOlETP5s24.OonsjKS.3rFtIJj3cNYF8PhVrJXj0Fc8YJYzXEQQiQVqumzew34xKEF4OgEylvo5MtnwfgLj6I49ZDqohZOmw8Gk61wHvJiVFDVyDD9B7.lO6F5KCFOOkg8RMJFOrpTFdqUBdtEgWyBvaEPxp.jV2.oWfG6EwBUK4nwySwGHTznoDHrWDJFYQU9yJ31RPBgpQ.4bZuHXyMZ370MaV2Fds02UCh7wJaNYp82a2ULiInM7hnferOWNgvM1quTd9tB+dTJ2AzAjtQDcFKFrWuDgmhIENa5GQt7HohDsXLm4Si1rt8zblypaKm7KaYeUsZUm0HlpL+scLehAq4C1EXMExPNh5ob.waP.fnIWq5EjH6PW.h4NkAiifLSGiDyZLAPjnOYAMxQEkP0jCcaP78ORlHf7.sYIhYbpyo4F+zlmU+l0tEV25rur0xcuD1cVca2lFLRBC4KFPhO2IzM0uRkptc1opEgJ7MHIGb20kubNSQMFTG4RcEs8djfaa8Ies9k4OZb5+fBQLHP7ZgbhylGSiUaVuYcs2j+CxVJNTpnCENaU6J.wWWy91rlNck7zlORx4ZecEr0U5Q+aJ5HRBlPipaeAgCgubAgz+x0T36ulpXIumwaKHnTbffoFFRE2Wi.TVHRW+kgJPTUZ02mkU8YRoQLnHaCrNBhRwawVdn2bPGhhjaEvfvgDRiTLM9s5Pu.ZIZpoqh6PiOWICgtaskAgRg93sv+Wm4uBxXoOpE4KfRvvwr2kCjc9q286uBUvjUUY80LlrGWRTPK8iYPnSa3OGWjjq9Dx7neityha17yzcx7IiC7bb6jXkLXLUo0MFMYVd+6pa.x+dsRP9cPIpnxTaUjbZnqxeXgupls8lchXW.cP9V6oDdLsdJoz3WIRCSTgIpRj1KY5TZjNhTh7XRPHmdDjJUhroG2diFTVXETWE.t0.o+sLCLPj1i3A4k.cc8dJ4zgc6F.sYTCR3JVHmcKv2lSIQ5IHsauBb0W5QzUE2xemjbWD7lXpNUd+92Gt5CckAdmBjssa13qpms3axV41nY9hV2PJaQqFMgumU6ZXV8clCAS.k9Ibhp7XQ8cAxX.dPoYQ54MhXlZQw6J7+1rxOTH9B7Hlxa9pwXkUfQn.9iAFytgwyvcgLTO0R.tNt2O8w45DHXxmt7b.QEwz8NNLIXLT34QgSWHnbceUqJ5Nfl8MyaqLFFfkt48vSFSW8dqLlt4LQADuH4a8L8M02g4IoT.LIRu91mf62ans6c6WF.kCu0yqrgtkZsdbp8xGmZa+PUCiOoa+GpRafOb3wcenZ8D7Q6dXmgCdn58T7fgcr+wen6GBP0cn1MA5qaJTPnAi5l1X1xpqf.4bo4mn+APXBroF

I keep coming back to this commented-out line 191 in PostGraphicsRenderer.cpp:

if (scale)
	{
		other = path;
		Rectangle<float> area(0.0f, 0.0f, bd.width, bd.height);
		PathFactory::scalePath(other, area);
		pathToUse = &other;
	}
	else if (scaleFactor != 1.0f)
	{
		other = path;
		//other.applyTransform(AffineTransform::scale(scaleFactor));
		pathToUse = &other;
	}

@Christoph-Hart should there be something in this spot to handle the non-1.0f scaling for applyMask? I've tried uncommenting the line, adding variations on the two lines from "if(scale)" to the "else if" section, and removing both conditionals/leaving the contents of "if(scale)", but no luck so far.

aaronventure

@Goodflow same as drop shadow from alpha.

Goodflow

@aaronventure I may be poking around the wrong part of the source code, then. The scaling op for that is in ScriptedDrawingActions.cpp, can't make sense of it though.

After a few tweaks to the snippet there's some progress:

"bool drawOnParent" should be false in the beginLayer call
the Path.addWhateverShape call should be done before beginLayer, then use fillPath inside the Layer before applyMask

This new snippet works on 50% scale and above on OSX , 75% and above on Windows.

HiseSnippet 1244.3ocsV0raaaDDdorYRjbZaBPe.H7IY.AUJY2jzZzFYqebMp9CVNtE0vHcE4Josd4tDjKsqhgA5gdtuQ8deM5aPeCZmkKoDorcpc.BunclYmY9lQyO6v.gCILTDfLJd7beBx3olilykyZNCS4nCagLdjojDJQ6O2GGFRbQFFqcfRlQw0Qwe+yq2GyvbGxRVHzIBpCoK0iJWxcXiumxXcvtjiodYt8NMNzQvaJXhH.GqYZi7wNmimR5iUWqfI.h1tToHXjDCfAYr99B24ilItjqu+IzP5XFQQTCMBLjlcGAyUgXEWTyYTl6vz3MDAVY3xneMcz+4l8ntzE7WlEdVr.qkZjMeXTHO7VKG7pkEd1Yf2s.IiLPZcMjdt4Hm.puboDEd1v7PtjDLACo8rPQeWTg+nfYSAbCtrpG9bRm.fXgFkegscEq511asaIHyGJsX3IVeiUa9TJmT0If.wwALwXLSautBw46wc6PHrxfNvsqFPlRCA60Ih6HoBd4McCvWdjPhClOhQcIAaVwZRpvoUrDi+ksrtpTohWfCrv0A2cJvpJFb1o0O6K1oxBpsyQAxpmSV8y1ErRohSqNAJm1iwJqKcBAL4Bnqn1E90.WjlCzgzPrblB+E8qUE65djHhC0GGQbjX9TFoLtdEqZ1ZSLs5XHB4cwyIAkmfYgDE+oUCIRs6V30oADBWKTAnXm3WKNfiwrVD12mMuGN77XYJOkZTkTB2U6oTmeS2b4LpLACpL8B2nL0NJyb8V6llusD79BIY.u7VktBL30krVUzjI2pLUBKPvXJnbKhUMtAuOEKyi7FSBpXcAlEQVbQnZNeKh4c2hjsC1Q++WlKJ3GxoxA9D9c0WiR9SW0NkfJ3px3loOMoYRWghntp4aGqluEi2rSvPu4vVXIN0JfAAm3SBjTE9MZQt.lvoaQKZ1hDdtT3CCqZJ77Ebk6Md7+mO+0k9i1X9RhusAzY4Oh9tT.03ue2u+5KotxYPly3u.NyHzoyjJpeBEGxK75FxjIYZu1gIvRJe5wTH6p78mYlkUsLfnwOmAD+FtQRXqiwmY1LJTJ7FQjJcCQimlNw9ol6T+kup1WYa+JaDTj5kcT9R55ZFwI0B+og4Ukrr1rU.8BXTwWq6FpDyJNyli0fHoejLGq8ilLgDnxQ4XOB64yHGAEY4XqGls+vd4urDZO8fnomvcEy3fYjNXGnhE3KChzri2psmGL2P1KhIo9L5JfuIifCTqJZ17VvUWgCV0urR7NN5lH3MgDUQ9AcuKb0EF+BxNEXaYYWsdkzCeY5osSOrS5gEhdQ5gWt3PhrZUsSOTeAqjC0qZC+dVoqQI0hoENQMRqGSKg62.cyUYvRTgaDCKyuYU8bhDAPtI25L0JKdHUNO6yMVcc652u0su+WCbeg6yMGRkNytc7V3VvKL.4iMdSd7xmX1F5IbjKA65lc9wONuTAAKOUyA5gkATXDhY+HuQPStCA7NmSXpY7FETilzz1JZU1XDrqKl3eguDg0TzFIBqkJD4gcBDu0QOCW87nmDyAvDO9kgO1ramAV0t4raOnA7sNN4MzJpU+CSss+vTamGpZllmzt6CUoGY1evwsenZ8Dyi1qeqA8dn5sgYuAsr9guq88AnpYh6EAKPzMMHTugsiWEXXzligZt35Sz+AH5Kxc.

bendurso

I'm still having the same issue. @d-healey are you still using cropped rounded png images to avoid this issue? I saw in other related post you used to do that :)

d.healey

@bendurso I'm using masks now. However below 1x scaling I run into the same issue, so as a workaround I've limited my plugin's minimum zoom to 1.

ustk

@d-healey @bendurso I started reporting those bad re-scaling of masks, shadows, and different layer operations years ago. Added to the very poor shadow efficiency (except for font), the paint methods really really need a cleaning/fixing session

Fergler

Another interesting thing. Content.createScreenshot will take a screenshot but the results have different mask scaling than the UI, even when my zoom is at 100% and everything looks correct.

aaronventure

@Fergler that mask is one of the final bosses of HISE UI stuff

applyMask behaves differently at different UI scales

24

1.7k

11.5k

100.4k