Still problems with Message.sendToMidiOut();

[ulrik]

@ps I'll do that

[ulrik]

@ps Ok, compiled as VST3, works here!

[ps]

@ulrik you must be kidding me!!!
What could be different on your side?
You have been able to record the generated midi (a# note)

[ulrik]

@ps the os, the preferences inside Hise, the settings in Hise Projucer file?

I'm on MacOs 13.0, using the Master code from yesterday, I'll check the Hise projucer settings, hold on...

[ulrik]

@ps Hmm..I have the default settings in Hise Standalone projucer file, if I remember correctly

[ulrik]

@ps said in Still problems with Message.sendToMidiOut();:

You have been able to record the generated midi (a# note)

I missed that, sorry, be back in a minute

[ulrik]

@ulrik Yes recorded successfully

[ps]

@ulrik I can’t believe it. I mean I’m on Mac m1 too - I’m on latest develop (which should be the same) - midi out does work for me in ableton for other plugins and you built my snippet haha - anything you might have different in your definitions than I could?

[ulrik]

@ps This is what I have

[ps]

@ulrik only thing I could come up with is maybe a different vst3 sdk but I'm gonna build master now - who knows haha

[d.healey]

@ulrik Post your compiled binary so @ps can confirm it's a HISE issue and not an Ableton or system issue.

[ps]

@d-healey yes that would be great, no need to code sign or anything. just the vst3. I did a clean build of the master no Faust no personal changes . still nothing.

[ulrik]

@ps Here's the vst3
TEST VST3

[ps]

@ulrik @d-healey ok as this also didn't work again I downloaded reaper and there it works (also the virtual instrument tests that I made. I guess it's on me now to find out what's going on in live - as I'm not the only one that will have this problem - thanks so much so far - I'll be back once I found the reason

[Lindon]

@ps said in Still problems with Message.sendToMidiOut();:

@ulrik @d-healey ok as this also didn't work again I downloaded reaper and there it works (also the virtual instrument tests that I made. I guess it's on me now to find out what's going on in live - as I'm not the only one that will have this problem - thanks so much so far - I'll be back once I found the reason

..and we will al be interested in that finding....

[ulrik]

@ps I hope you'll find the issue, and that will benefit us all, good luck!

[ps]

@Lindon @ulrik @d-healey I can't believe it suddenly I am this one customer that has an unsolvable problem that you happily offer a refund.... I tried it on another Mac (intel) and it works here as well.
Clean install of live on my M1 incoming.

BUT WHY THE HELL DO OTHER PLUGINS WORK....

[ulrik]

@ps Good finding
That all other plugins work is a bit worrying, there is something fishy with how this is working/not working, in Hise/in our way of writing code?

[ps]

@ulrik let's see if a clean install of ableton will do the trick - even if it works then not 100% confident to sell a plugin that relies on that feature but as an additional feature it should be fine. Let's see. Maybe I really was the 0.1% user now.

[ps]

@ulrik @d-healey @Lindon I just opened the best bottle of rum I could find and will have a little celebration - it works!

So I don't know what exactly has been the case - as self thought idiot that never learned how to use computers properly I know that with my first attempts writing scripts in whitebox packages for my installers I did some harm in the Application Support Folder leading to some weird stuff later on - now looking up all the files that I need to remove for a proper uninstall of Live there was quite a bit of stuff in the folders that I could have harmed - this is just me very vaguely trying to calm myself down that this will not be a common problem - if it happens - clean reinstall as instructed on the ableton website will do the trick ;)

I will implement midi out in current projects now and in 2 weeks latest I can tell you if it's safe or if I had to hire more support staff ;)