Server.callWithGET broken on Mac compiled plugins

orange

@Christoph-Hart This is the exported fx plugin, you can see yourself: https://www.dropbox.com/s/b4qq5z8qopwlzzo/ServerTest_FX.zip?dl=1

Also snippet of this plugin is in below. In Hise works, instrument plugin works, but compiled fx plugins doesn't work in LPX.

HiseSnippet 1645.3ocuXssbZaDFVxwaRrbbmjYxE8RMzafo1bvw4PSm1.FiSoECLVX61qRERKvFK1kJsXBwimI8IpuB8QpuAs+qNwJrD1wyjpKX1C+eq99Ot+nttLKrmGyUQcidymfUTeDxXNkOp9HSBUo4A9Kfcu.61C6wU1e9DSOOrshp58dqPB0MVWw+4edy9lNlTK7hkTTNkQrvsHiI7Eq1s5uPbbNzzF2iLVR58p1zhQqybXSA1bOTYkIlVmaND21TH1ZHE062vlvYtFbSN1SQc88Y1yMFwlQCj+ThGouCVLohhAbPAKeHywVvXwpJ0GQbr6Fo0dJvozcgM3dA1fmhNhXShWegs3w9anu.gr8PcsUQuJxzq7smdpRza8.58DjgkKYBewNBtsIpIkicGXBt.YZEHqxZ+0CP0YfDTdwwlmiOzElDiH+KJWda8mWtbguWSCbCdb8KLc0YTGBE2pui9OnGAdHlWmMdBiBSxmKVhb.xE.wiMINqBWj.IgIX8Llq8pPJISRvdfcep2pfFKQRftXOPBuUpmRxjDLGBhcWExHARByzhStfvmuJjRxH.qEaqK5gEGL9C7baqGjcVj30we67EzeidtNsa0rcib5uFFd3g9igSHV+Sb.4L7WVHfjVlTjiC2PHTjBkTBQxrqXaIVmThlsqUuWyS8YB7lFpaY5.Ldn.IrhVnh.X12zCexwsxmaDmOw60kJMa1rhTFwCa5MpnEabI+ynTI8tcL5oQ7Ub8ASovqlQgnVwIeFgOpKyiuOmJLutLm7VQ11sAefyTbAsK01fLPOe3Lc34R+eEORzCbQMnCgWhvCcxDgEHOvfHIiG3aDJBlYWt+v7OqbZhkge3rZM60r8a0M5Uq2IF506bPihEKlS5Dxz+DA83FFc6z1XYbwCbXfVAoYtPMUH02CTrKyM0C6RgEx8537VgdFd5E1NFcZOw4i.ZoTS4C3pTHRnyN1QA9w74lMYm26wnkd+L9NlS4iJcQkRb14XJnhK371wd57AFxsisKEhO+KSP5H+BaRfaQxzjfUY6b3thpjA6UXI3Y4UBvDyMITWEN9JMv1jdx+Rgv4JHN5v.45vd8gKGymUjdgj4SAihQEa9lYR3PDtHMPvlrxbCESTWILCVTWQNc9J+W3hpa9V4EIMVtX3JQ+E6z+8XKtvAD5SvAYJWmb7HZkZ8lvS1lMEtRsGyf6BLL+0SR02QNOda8cKn+s547vVQzVppQaFG2gl2upf1UZ5Ku0fAotWnM2QDWkx1gQbYCLOc539XW4ZRBAgq6S1OAJ69Ija2wJHbRRPFsIkv6LASypKCkvXPXzIMOvjaJZ7HbMPtIXWNQPA0CvW.czEzFxFnCvdmC4TJpZwAtvxb+c+pvlT1eJmynJDaQeKKEsp7gEs+QpNOdR0eupvMK52pdsVszOqYuexuTuBw6H1X30X5NOPWlQr4ijOkQXxvQRsa1qpm4E3lztPdHlGXhTtNc2JjtsL6ic7YqFJpXnLM+MIZ9oet5Ru94W60+igZBz9Z+gQM29HTkx6Utxqd4y9tJJC.yrA4iRcBWt5shfagjp2lEGqd5+GbTKKNtIJtokrb1JOs5M5DOnJFRELi6dNM9DnCODEz5SVZhLq2LaVGeIfDqqhk88muDqqNIEVGwofNrxhS2rtIVK3uAsEpF01zAqeDixRnMOJ63DoKnj8B6IqO+wR5ym9yqoOjP8QCE0N3sSiLcHCoi8I48QN3AbkrzmaJNayrSVitkP1g8QIE7u6ubXlcJNrUD+mFeCrGO.4WiOE1u6Rws2JcYKjzEwY4u9BpNZnnq1+L0nLqT8Pj+3JxJyWKWBnYjxfTOClFoHH0uAlEYjabTslsjCld.x0WNeVxmKnz8gKIcr+rX0tWiUH0dvvajQZnt0LLNqywGbKI00+m7OFcDydpiIO4GYP7kUB2.5THw+lW7O1odPrg7Wd4KxWd31R2mf5R3ViRmuqkBegdK9Ry2vuiyVnFCF.satfrqiN7W+x+QaTNlMUzw7QlPaoPzEp8zwFPZnEFXBkhcDcyotlnuqf4kEyEVFCL01ex+BOgaVQLWMbyJQapL1zxk8NqfdHEeonG5uBvIpep8FniDy0qn32WIfCUtXYkwDax6rrDlhc.tmNlcuCXd1c.yd2ALO+Nf4E2ALu7Nf4UqDi3aGVaJmMNHMAVnaC+lsUUaPEkT8iHU9OWkXzqC

NOTE: Create an account for login from here: https://www.noiseash.com/my-account/

Natan

@orange What's The Purpose Of This?
Plugin Activation?
Downloading On The Fly?

orange

@Natan said in Server.callWithGET broken on Mac compiled plugins:

@orange What's The Purpose Of This?
Plugin Activation?
Downloading On The Fly?

It can be both of them

Natan

@orange Hmmm Sounds Intresting

ulrik

@LeeC Good finding :)

ustk

Hi all,
I have to bring some more information on this server plugin test.
The Timer start and the server call are not in relation with each other. Although they are triggered inside the same button callback, this is done sequentially, one after the other (timer first then server call)

This is important to know because it tells us none of them are triggered at all when the playhead is stopped. This why I don’t think it’s a timer or server issue anymore…

Could Logic have a function like the one we find in ProTools, that put the plugin in standby when it’s not playing or even between audio containers like ProTools can do?

This might explain these functions are bypassed or not triggered…

@Christoph-Hart Does it make sense?

ustk

I’d like to add that the timer and the server are launched, but they are in standby (we can see the server thread is ACTIVE)

So maybe Hise could « disapprove » this forced standby for vital functions like server and timer, what do you think @Christoph-Hart?

LeeC

Think you might be right that it's not a timer or server issue @ustk.

Here's a cleaner example of the behaviour in Logic Pro X.

As you can see, movement of the playhead is actually not required to 'Activate' the plugin, running a simple test tone through the plugin is enough to get things moving.
Furthermore once this is done, the plugin stays 'Activate' for the entire session (as closing and reopening the plugin demonstates).

alt text

ustk

@LeeC Good catch again!
So this is definitely a LP restriction… the question is, can Hise go through this restriction ?

LeeC

@ustk said in Server.callWithGET broken on Mac compiled plugins:

@LeeC Good catch again!
So this is definitely a LP restriction… the question is, can Hise go through this restriction ?

Yep that is the big question!

I also attempted a hack around...
By playing audio internally using Scriptnodes Audio Player within a compiled plugin, hoping that this would 'Activate' the plugin but unfortunately not.

It seems that certain parts of a HISE compiled plugin lay dormant in a session until LPX passes audio through it.