Issue macro taking the priority

[Oli Ullmann]

@DanH
And here is the whole thing again with a macro modulator:

@ustk maybe this is also interesting for you...

HiseSnippet 2356.3oc2Y0saabbEdHoVYK5313lTjh.TfEJ8BoBABQIJKmFTnU+QYBGIwHRIazaTGs6rjC3tyrc+QRzAFn.sW3aJ5k4YoW07.jBDT+Bz9.Tfzm.2yLytb2UjlhlUVAIzvBbNyeem+OygM84ljf.tOpP4188HnBumVq9rvta2ESYnF6fJLmlK2ZGhKGsUeObP.wBUnPo8DSWXtYPxOe2FagcvLSRJID5DN0j74TWZXJ0lFOg53TGaQZScyr5ZFML4rs4N7H.JkzVF4gM6g6PN.KVVQMziwAcQE90ZKWyD+nUrWa0U+zOc80rNiXZWkb15l3kWCauFFnVCWasp0PElcWKZH2uUHNjD.G5Vbq9s5xufotfSnAzybHhAUQsfaVQFscWpiUyD4R.BNnloRoRJozGpsO0hNfdpz58kSnmtirBsBEGGjp9V.oBYfzLJH8.sVl9TuvzYD34dZMXgDeaLnaxBE0ZQE+KE01lCqfEVwE2iT2GFLXGK7vkWdIc3OK9YkKuKqCkQpfsr1maE4PjLQa9wAD+l9j.R3ByumC+LritbdLvm5hiFjLD+pyCGAngCB0cc0+s5wGloOANj30S4r8wg9zKu1CJ4j3VMXzPAPhBfC8KKqqOeKhCwLDChwVfsDHIl+2nG5GQVRL4NDabjSnXWmfchjSJ1EL01Qgbaa3FGPBHBCIv34aYhcHyuTBYg.hEPC6CyUsxxozCNf66hcnOmXEesxodA72WHAvQXVGBng7H9gzAW+KJ+hxkccq.BQkDHUhjt1ExwtBo.HTB3NjJd9TV3Bg9BMFbJcF6or3hK9Y1QLSAYcN6.dH4P1BKV9KKOGfB8qNks8HmSnO74NND+QNsv41ebabAVj6YD+kzOWnFFrPvXNuGxrSlGhoxDNyB4Lgr5POR735bGKgku36C6Ogh8A.OqhwHDVZnzu5mD6W0xgZQ7QT3Pti1SX7yphjfOIHlwe6eZfl3MuR9MKBghNtwN3Prv6NFNopMf1Njyg3oJe84z1gDzKj6IwqqGmI.ege50h3KGbg+wdF8SuclgK0xxgzjCl0flRLSIwDdekQPHwqEXRmEqtYi9WyvEmdvu7UFAQ11Tfhll9ieNBraIh.Q08I+gHByrOxKQz2vRlvQhV85OqJD02GB3CgeDybWMkSIxUZN2F6Cl1hItm1.uUDMj3lj2XtYQnWaK.QH4xP4Abb6CqWWneGHjl6Z0LuAgj9EFW4x9Ou9qRur6ns+laezgCA1xZ6iM84Brliu+XEc8XSlzfcWQJ7dp0IiWAIPGJtOjwIYmYSCIRPmF.HWr+AguxpQeKxMs7XyMMoP7AZMoglcGMFKNBLJbNeGfw3L52WaWaaHyQJ.mQq9yl1z2S90eW00+wZpbdoBpjLdRr7K0FSJwwTX12NoEl4MwElc0PzSeQLy7tptpYlLEy0jSXBsi+fgTMA2hda4pDbtAvLNhiBORXNlvMWKZ2h5wcv9h4gx8ZikHK0dRdvMXVjKyRskKmG1Mu0D0PtV4IHy0Ipr+Fqp3ajHOklnHO23VXSeTnaFnbDOJjx5nJbDxbePjqp9Y.ILFwAtHsBEEUJoFurXrTMSXVxAuF9DOYUw3BwSVMYRj5vyTiCiXpJ13NiN299xJGhuGIZhsxTjFos5lQWdESwu6uKoMBsZC14P4UJwZVkwGoTF2S6o3yIxmCKUE+b4XanDe88HPf2g8ddmG78P3oMmSZ6iYAd7.R0bNbDWZanHmfbTuxNVYj6HG0cHgQr7GshTtUIDE0AQQl0cWiDhqjkXSLK2gAiycR6Synr9WarKS93MBv4VGFXBBFYLrLp3lQNAjmRsB6VM6FSIuRVxOF6aA5PybtyklXenrgbxWSUl0ea1zfa0jaeOVG4nyr0h554P1Ebbcf2FIw3OSK9Y8ITy6StOmw85xYzbV.GQfXQc5PxYXM5.JggXydoT9PiiHNDbPF+zekwmCEhg8UwqlJYwae+dFo95WnofqtHPh9+O5saUyrebkQ9lwjOVdUN9cpvcJt7buVdDMzqvK0Ra2hmOAdJIoMuoCt+BAXgqyQ.FWR+LGtYOwi5GtGMwORcKwJVvLN6+zzJmYuoJq61n1jAM.Bc.I7BteOo5H96vqzTx9.oP9T6Kqh1zwgegnsBzXKVPGHo0j6zOIdSgRpUjfzMc4QhdPnfap49VIpiDj+XbPaL0Q7R3VQAd.TOj0BNGYwDEJcBwOPU3j1xUf+AdCGHi8bm5XSPl2uIFpYAbqLSdjXEyA1u4XirlPpdsmaZwolT+gBY.C4J6iBT4tPa1LoWEhdTUrPoL8rRYOKFAdtEUWcifSDyZhcPpNZ.aRdKJ4sjIlUrTMsfysQ4Xm6qYScD2TEwTCib0VFOjyCPYegbHCpIst57S+p.2IkbJrS1EL0sf.HpGuDa6jQDHx6mLBX28orSx2luZvKftLOsW9JiVC0hMv9rG4BE6GS03O49O1P0S+zVo0lbYXaUyg.SXY4r94WQSbG0ufRqny1ymG4IGjGBF+Ui3bnCQOaMxaBUl6hUCJhxvnkuBiZr5puZiqvne827MexjwnnO4+9sRFsj1W7FYviA0hMXYaMQLHjfajLnnsqigOfOq70CovPqLg7grlBfOlUVE0afUD8x0jdFwYxXDQw3ihQjEVONFQ7N8KGh6mHF42+A67pXKO0q5gnw2HJFi+8y+yiRwHoOE7y6OBECviiQwHKY6FxF6ctpYbrxbZpGNYca5wnhwmxa2WfjAss+lO5GnsxGZe2Kg6kMnsoxbhk01gFnDEilQGMeUy35iklMX3PrQ1VZDb0NbHyOK5ugJIUyrc3O6Mf1hy64hk0eLU+fPS9K6f2c+CmWH7QZGFXtht7YB5e++NgaiRRuMtCWQ6XO0TUIuvn8tRJ.eyjkTMWbWiqd0etRDxkZQO0zL4nJTvL42D15TuL0.QmveqKwAI9IGGP3TEDdP7dSamcte7Q.H3rM6aCnD7ry1k1oa1oCf.K4FCAextdZFWbeB1hyb5KJ2wLMhv5ZqtdEV6G9jGs8V60Y6JUNY253kOtZynZNl8Zrm3+U1bmlOi9EO82U835v2OuRkJHznksqbsx12vFWcZ2XsociqMsa7gS6FWeZ23it9MJZ5VbIshPIPV3l6pJruPRtTQig+eyuu6k.

[ustk]

@Oli-Ullmann Nice, I didn't see we could connect the macro knob to the MacroValue parameterId...

However when moving the real macro knob (from the Macro Control panel) and if the CUTOFF slider is a pluginParameter then it move accordingly so something still feels wrong here...

I feel more comfortable with my solution of making a modulator that mimics the macro behaviour. Perhaps in some cases it might be limited but for now it seems to fit my project just fine, so I don't have any reason to use the stock macro system anymore unless somebody shows me if I am missing the obvious

[DanH]

@ustk @Oli-Ullmann Thanks guys, hugely appreciated. Big job ahead of me!

I don't necessarily need poly modulation in most of my modules but I do want the most accuracy if possible, hence I'd like to use the Mod Matrix Module - for that I need this system, correct?

Also, sometimes enabling External Modulation doesn't create the slot index I need for the extra_mod node. Anyone else experiencing this?

[Oli Ullmann]

@ustk
The advantage of my snippet is that you can assign the Macro Controller like any other modulator. So via drag and drop, right-click, or via the Modulation Matrix UI elements. It all feels like a closed system.
But maybe I'm misunderstanding something and your method works like that, too.

@DanH yes for sample-accurate modulation, you actually need the MatrixModulator. Unfortunately, I can't help with the problem with the indexes.

[ustk]

@Oli-Ullmann said in Issue macro taking the priority:

@ustk
The advantage of my snippet is that you can assign the Macro Controller like any other modulator. So via drag and drop, right-click, or via the Modulation Matrix UI elements. It all feels like a closed system.
But maybe I'm misunderstanding something and your method works like that, too.

Yes it's working all the same since they are modulators in the global container

[DanH]

@Oli-Ullmann Thanks! Managed to print the enormous list of available knobs from the console. Now to use AI to add in the missing fields! Do you know the exact text for the Modes? i.e BiPolar / Bipolar / bipolar ?

[Oli Ullmann]

@DanH
Yes, you find the modes here:
https://docs.hise.dev/scripting/scripting-api/scriptmodulationmatrix/index.html#setmatrixmodulationproperties

["Scale", "Unipolar", "Bipolar"]

[DanH]

@Oli-Ullmann @ustk Am I running into a bug here? Have tried both FreqLog and Freq presets but they both behave the same, i.e wrongly! The skew is totally off.

[Oli Ullmann]

@DanH
I believe these two presets are only for filter cutoff, not for EQ bands. I can try again for EQ bands at the beginning of next week.

I also have a modulatable EQ in my plug-in. I solved it so that the knobs directly control the corresponding bands (via the callback) and then used the matrixTargetId and no matrixModulator, because monophonic, non-sample-accurate modulation is sufficient for me.

[DanH]

@Oli-Ullmann yeah fair enough. These are filters though, so it should work. I made the eq in scriptnode