Are the HISE LFO's accurate enough?
-
Hi @Christoph-Hart, I'm Using LFO's in an FX plugin and they don't seem to snap to the beat accurately.
Tested in Logic and Ableton, Win and OSX. I've tested using a filter + LFO on the Frequency - Snippet at the bottom.
I assume they should be bang on the beat / grid, but when hitting play you can see the plotter has a spike from the last bit of the LFO Waveform and, crucially, you can hear that the filter is open for a tiny bit before closing... Image and gif below:
HiseSnippet 2036.3oc2Y8tbabaD+NIcIQzI1Itd5j9MLb5LgZphBI0err8zoTVhzlSjrnEYhamLcRgtCjBU2AbEGNIy55oesOV4QnyzWj9Fzt.3HOblmUnXbSTJ+.k.1+fcWr6uE.rmf6SRR3BG2UGLNl339gd8Gyjms+YXJyo6ANtU7NrywnAs6Ov4wiiwIIj.GW2kehht6pq3n+7u+cOFGhY9j7obb9ZN0mbHMhJymsWqujFF1AGPFPir3dqVc84r84g7TvVV1qtSL1+b7HxyvJ1Vxyw88ZGPkbQeIVRRbbW4w7fw8OieIyv+WSSnmFRTCZ3zGTjY5N7v.kEql0Y+yngA8l3yINNtd8xi.Kah.2y6HZ.c574QhOVS.kKgc7vcohl2xELuF1lWcKyqDSx0xjVwXRehWeeAMVlSQYO2xqKSRDCwPX21TL75rzwdd6yANXxMhvmS5HfASkn1N0quNB9ZsGUoxW7En8EDvvQXjTfYIwbgDcFlEDRDUPvNShDcAVjS7oFZneKpMaDkQ1vWK+f2fdMP6nJHP+CNifFInAHebX3ovdKhQHAIHIGcJAQXXH3DfFxg0.3DR4zRATSFy7QTYBIbnZnhpeH2+7MpLi0rQBQ1Vqom.qTMoHkrNZ2BlfVTzkPNHhwuDEKHCIlkj7RHxvvgYrj.Ih9jM.gnIZoiHvhAbhkHbBJjyFo9aIRRSXelDIRYLJajVzZJtNXuWfhCwi09NMAkH4wwjf0.eyXOoIDs5nLa0oU.3dpEKgyYSVzYUGVHgH3DsIHp.mV57fWDV5eVt37DpjxYkGHAX.+i3AjZyPrmNn0NyqmFd6qrfR7.SLzXU93IdoBTArHHLoElbAggnCQWQjZCTMfgw7TDGfT.NARgPpmIQISkY6rRTD+BBJkEBkKWU7ZsRSiTz5l4D6q7gZ0MtoUk.Mjb.VhgJfWUAUUUmV8gnp8B4RPtpqCyMsZsaP0GVUYcP7LMDCnDMzLzkEPdY0G1P8+FnOkFq9vJH0mWY9i5S0SGYnCKQ8WVecKJTIIxhVmNad+Mau0tkyRCMOau8r7Hgj3RTigiWaLPMTBP9a9i5woBALd.9TkDUPu9QFlqfl.5Lh.pLJlyfA0p1IjikPEw.Hv0r5ZpTrLFUNcsIwy0dzvTluJsDwYOiKIGypsVkWUY0JutB5MIMbXozT5UvC03OkPV04QbUBVikFcJQrNrQGlRlxH.GWDi26siwa2Bx23lVLxYcYT4wwD1aqwjSVrA5GrRlUArJ0cCtcV2f9gz.hvgFLoI8I6Mnsi1lsZC2xYNj+C0x2+niOdvSmQCNyiFtqVC8d5d8aiNtSm9sGrX54VFK4o60aFW4CZ47UcU4HpljYwGHlESDRpZ6v8.xEvINLsLW06.Rx4.xgi66OMKDlVl0i2rv1Ik5k+Nd1S0v4kSW9VjViyG7mZkY.lUCDiFB08GPSTfLNSpWUQ1sZtais2Z6satoSdkngvC15A6b+lOXaKBMUTZ1XmsZtS8c2YSGs+59kdJzfhHJnpl0TikLELA84MzCgy8Dxu7Ebw4IvIoTXSCwgIjJuVsKLMbT4ZENZ9VCG7hgiU8xvAsBDpJAa+u33llIxggLiMd+yK06mEPMOHr.wfqtpJ2wcFX43e2kshfdjpz1ADPipllNQXKtueqDIItO8uRrOsbDM.5zzKqAbNkOqUbtSpNwYQmDNTr.NOLDX6pKU5HH+kTByebAG58muxbq8x+bQW5ZXC2wqeDmC8hUYHvI0K36+gV1l06ccvNrLtzE139HudmgSTsIflMEBQqNW3OukHD5uccLha68B7EjNbQjt1Hp30lJDutWo4JKd85lVdv2Mxtd8uWrdsh1FgCeGcEEryIfU4kvmbsKg+9wwl8dRvMzlnM6qsotqZFAU0l8ckTmxiAUgisi3uytK27ZhehWOJbx7xswkJwFgNf+uvFytA7G40d3PhuL2.Wwqyu+Ggq6l8FD20qGObb7YbF02ziSaDql0jswU7PDNN4XhSl7e7uZ8b6s2izH1SF+osddJN7MhtOlFyCwhenQ9FWsquxbld7KyA5Q+jjGWXS5NFK0Sg5kUf8F3eeuF1r6Q.lj5Qg5VXqbBnT1gJldLvCIifExVg4MeslrXmIK8dHmGadmf.a9saVXwsRsC3GgArYg9xf1xreJb6znonmpGppOfga.89Fuc1ZC3yvei56GrO70lG+tY76vrvklyrvegdad59oZC+FHTpwJKTubiDvWAagtQ2T5W4kgBpil2rs0a687e5MvaaLva40mxH5WQOC8VMFovHPOgvHhYAIK1C6eNuOld7b+X5G6KgkO60YSJn39jH5.33kI1S9UID0l9Ipvo876ywhRIAX5fSVpL8wxTgdeYuHdJq.1p6xW0i52XAeT+Utw8n9+L3rpkcPrOFRcihCIsYWPB4vLJa7tdGPFhSCkSlsXt7QbF2bzM6M5SHRAczHhv11K0g1SJw18XuWqSHgDrcR6ut0gPxFVT7fbWqXQiq8uASo6WepmwbQpBPzOeuiwx+e8cLbNgmptS7QXHIDtRr2yRi5q+8cfUmwHgp2x0cIE9lYbc0XC3HKPO3+.exH1PM1MiXiID+QYMhv9B925adEUUd5GnmA7al9mIcUuiTiQMl7zodd02ntSDfv8s99pP7mC.lkKSyEPlMW.Y1ZAjY6EPlcV.Yt+BHytWoLplK6kBWQvTxASzqs4xAtSuAh6xN+WX6lH1K
-
@DanH I've just done a test with an instrument. Using the ramp shape in the LFO you can clearly see a little peak when I play notes nearly every time, showing that the LFO isn't starting the modulation from zero as I would expect it to. Moving the smooth function to 0 prevents this.
@Christoph-Hart is there perhaps an issue with LFO smoothing in FX pugins?