Collaborative project!

[hisefilo]

@d-healey CollaB3 installer from github >>> (standalone CollaB3 .exe passes. Installer does not)

[d.healey]

Must be something to do with the way you made the installer, did you use a script or was it done manually?

[ustk]

@hisefilo @lalalandsynth @d-healey

Some news from my friend keyboardist/sound engineer!

Here's my translation focused only on the bugs and issues for now. There are some great suggestions as well but I keep that for the pro version ;)

To begin with, BRAVO!!! What a great piece of work!!!!
It seems amazing to me to realize such a thing... I hope there will be a lot more!!

1 - Leakage
It seems that the leakage is not "just". It's moving harmonically but the accuracy is not great...
Which sometimes creates dissonances depending on the drawbars that are used. I don't find this issue on the Arturia for instance...

2 - Drawbars
Lack of some medium on 16, 5 1/3, 8
A bit too much of medium/high on 1 1/3

Sound disappears form C4 on drawbar 1

3 - Rotary
There's a kind of numeric saturation when changing speed
=> I'm aware of that from the beginning and I already smoothed it but I can't do it more. I think it's something's broken in scriptnode and we might need to wait for V3 for a solution...

Might need to be more open, with more "air" and "grit"

4 - Chorus
Seems to act more like a vibrato

DONE
*5 - Reverb
Allow for going up to 100% wet*

6 - Preset Browser
RENAME does not work
=> I've never noticed that before but it doesn't work here either on my mac, haven't tested on windows/linux...
Although my own plugins work so it might be the Hise build that has been used...?

DONE
*7 - Level
Marking on the knob would be helpful*

[hisefilo]

@d-healey I can't remember but installers were made at your end?
The one I compiled was using build.bat from repo

[d.healey]

I made a Windows installer on the 7th, but I thought you made a more recent one than that.

@hisefilo said in Collaborative project!:

Installers done. Notarised also.
Win Mac Commodore64

@d-healey are you able to do the linux one???

[d.healey]

I just tested the installer I made on the 7th

[hisefilo]

@d-healey I was about to ask for that! So weird. I just used the .bat on repo
Maybe my Inno version? Ive downloaded Inno just before creating the installer

[d.healey]

@hisefilo My installer is in the repo, see what happens when you upload it to virus total, maybe it doesn't like you :p

[hisefilo]

@d-healey LOL!!! Can you re-do the installer using the lastest commit?? your version has the old leslie and chorus. Maybe we need to point that as release on github

[ustk]

@hisefilo @d-healey Have you checked my report above guys?
It might worth to add some quick bug fix before recompiling…

[d.healey]

@ustk Yeah, let's do 1.0.1 before next release.

[ustk]

@d-healey Agree...
Reverb and Level mark are done and pushed
Also, I added a "Release Notes" file

[hisefilo]

@ustk @d-healey Okidoki let's go for 1.0.1 :)

[ustk]

For information, I just came across this one
Sounds amazing... But the price is in consequence!
https://www.ikmultimedia.com/products/hammondb3x/

[hisefilo]

@d-healey can't sleep guessing what was it. and figured it out. .dll 64 bits shows positive malware. I recompiled same one using older Hise commit and passed. I guess something gives a false positive on .dll x64 built with Hise commit 30Jan2020

[hisefilo]

@ustk those guys have the best B3 nowadays

[lalalandsynth]

If we are doing fixes , someone told me that the midi learn of the drawbars were inverted ?
Have not been able to verify that , dont have a controller here .

[hisefilo]

@lalalandsynth sounds possible since we inverted them for UI.

[hisefilo]

@ustk said in Collaborative project!:

1 - Leakage
It seems that the leakage is not "just". It's moving harmonically but the accuracy is not great...
Which sometimes creates dissonances depending on the drawbars that are used. I don't find this issue on the Arturia for instance...
2 - Drawbars
Lack of some medium on 16, 5 1/3, 8
A bit too much of medium/high on 1 1/3
Sound disappears form C4 on drawbar 1

1. I need to re do that. It's an exhaustive and long process if I will to re-create leakage to the subatomic detail. Can we leave that for a pro version?

2. mmmm I guess gain tables should have different values to each drawbar???

[ustk]

@lalalandsynth So we might need to re-export the filmstrips inverted...

@hisefilo Yeah I don't know if t is essential to do that now if it's too much work.
Although when working on the pro version it might be good training to begin with this one maybe, but later if you prefer...

I have no idea for the rest, but I tried the C4 issue.
In fact, I can still hear a few notes above C4, but very dimmed. So they're here but the value might be wrong...