Still problems with Message.sendToMidiOut();

[ulrik]

@ps I don't know, have not tried yet

[ulrik]

@ps Yes it's working

[ps]

@ulrik ok i also added the floating tile keyboard and nothing... everything looks the same as on your end but no midi from the fx plugin...

can you do me the massive favor and check the snippet I posted a few posts above and see if it works for you as vst3 instrument.

Also your plugin works in plugin host but not in ableton for me so if my snippet works for you also in the daw and you are able to route midi out of the instrument and record the generated midi on an empty midi track ( it should be a# notes only whatever you input) there is something super strange going on on my end but I also might get some ideas.

[ulrik]

@ps I'll do that

[ulrik]

@ps Ok, compiled as VST3, works here!

[ps]

@ulrik you must be kidding me!!!
What could be different on your side?
You have been able to record the generated midi (a# note)

[ulrik]

@ps the os, the preferences inside Hise, the settings in Hise Projucer file?

I'm on MacOs 13.0, using the Master code from yesterday, I'll check the Hise projucer settings, hold on...

[ulrik]

@ps Hmm..I have the default settings in Hise Standalone projucer file, if I remember correctly

[ulrik]

@ps said in Still problems with Message.sendToMidiOut();:

You have been able to record the generated midi (a# note)

I missed that, sorry, be back in a minute

[ulrik]

@ulrik Yes recorded successfully

[ps]

@ulrik I can’t believe it. I mean I’m on Mac m1 too - I’m on latest develop (which should be the same) - midi out does work for me in ableton for other plugins and you built my snippet haha - anything you might have different in your definitions than I could?

[ulrik]

@ps This is what I have

[ps]

@ulrik only thing I could come up with is maybe a different vst3 sdk but I'm gonna build master now - who knows haha

[d.healey]

@ulrik Post your compiled binary so @ps can confirm it's a HISE issue and not an Ableton or system issue.

[ps]

@d-healey yes that would be great, no need to code sign or anything. just the vst3. I did a clean build of the master no Faust no personal changes . still nothing.

[ulrik]

@ps Here's the vst3
TEST VST3

[ps]

@ulrik @d-healey ok as this also didn't work again I downloaded reaper and there it works (also the virtual instrument tests that I made. I guess it's on me now to find out what's going on in live - as I'm not the only one that will have this problem - thanks so much so far - I'll be back once I found the reason

[Lindon]

@ps said in Still problems with Message.sendToMidiOut();:

@ulrik @d-healey ok as this also didn't work again I downloaded reaper and there it works (also the virtual instrument tests that I made. I guess it's on me now to find out what's going on in live - as I'm not the only one that will have this problem - thanks so much so far - I'll be back once I found the reason

..and we will al be interested in that finding....

[ulrik]

@ps I hope you'll find the issue, and that will benefit us all, good luck!

[ps]

@Lindon @ulrik @d-healey I can't believe it suddenly I am this one customer that has an unsolvable problem that you happily offer a refund.... I tried it on another Mac (intel) and it works here as well.
Clean install of live on my M1 incoming.

BUT WHY THE HELL DO OTHER PLUGINS WORK....