HISE Logo Forum
    • Categories
    • Register
    • Login

    MidiChannel is always 1 in NoteOn when logging midi players output

    Scheduled Pinned Locked Moved Scripting
    6 Posts 2 Posters 256 Views
    Loading More Posts
    • Oldest to Newest
    • Newest to Oldest
    • Most Votes
    Reply
    • Reply as topic
    Log in to reply
    This topic has been deleted. Only users with topic management privileges can see it.
    • ulrikU
      ulrik
      last edited by ulrik

      If I have a MidiPlayer playing a midi file with all events on channel 2, in NoteOn callback logging with Message.getChannel() , I get channel 1, why is that?

      Hise Develop branch
      MacOs 15.3.1, Xcode 16.2
      http://musikboden.se

      ulrikU 1 Reply Last reply Reply Quote 0
      • ulrikU
        ulrik @ulrik
        last edited by

        @ulrik I ask because I want to see from which MidiPlayer the note on events is coming if I use more than 1 MidiPlayer.
        Or is there another way to distinguish from which it's coming?

        Hise Develop branch
        MacOs 15.3.1, Xcode 16.2
        http://musikboden.se

        ulrikU 1 Reply Last reply Reply Quote 0
        • ulrikU
          ulrik @ulrik
          last edited by

          @ulrik
          Here's a small snippet using 2 MidiPlayers, player1 has events on channel 1, player2 on channel 2

          Logging the midi events from the 2 players shows that it's working

          Looking in NoteOn cb show midi channel 1 from both players

          midiplayers.gif

          HiseSnippet 4195.3oc2a08TiikcWFZ2aauYRM6tytYeIUogZqJlfG0VFiaHyNYvxV.F7GpwFZfN8NQHcss.YIijrASpopox+XYeHUdNOkmyeB6+AcNm6URVx1.Fllo1ItJD5dum64967w8bN5KEGaMhqqsCWhTsGOfvk3uIYqwVd8J2S0vhqZEtDuLoGw0iSZ7.UWWhNWhDKuKNVhTufi96u7sRplpVZjIcwwcrsgFolQeCuI8pr8AFll6npSZazOB0E1tplsUYaS6g.NVNYNtApZWp1kzPEIaoj.Hj0M7rcZ4oBfgKwKjr0G2pm80VL5O1v03bSB1PjqEvHV26XapiHF6kqbOCSck.40kiKQRkIR+xLo+KRV2P2Hr+IZgOmN.+jYDUejXo3va4XvS7tf2bfzxQfzuHvfPgjo5XhCEJoSVm0RLFHJOzwgX40hb0PRLiwe4a8GpsCnVi1eMa6AxVp.zzi1Mx8yARaMfDefDK+IRN4PQZGCSBJyIBZ.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.BVA4yj4UWwElx6o4rvYDK7clUBhTtxpYSmB9w+.DlekU+PH+YcMG9S6+AYdbphw45JsTZIhLd9BaiFsTnrkeN+l+TNVt1idN0jYqyT.K+8Cr7OAfk+I.LlFadSZ9cFHAJpVDS23NRkLMCYuKZSnDEwWBEbpklYZx5qIPMiCoKOZPqY35QI48eHK+6+.LTXuBNDWhyHRl74xQczw4nb.k5nJW2RZdFiffbO.5BHCAX3bogMefIRoYE+sZ39kiKU6HY9ZMadvQJ7sKIUSNXWWiigXBWdDDpvwvpKhzUDes3JY4g+kuh++WIaZ3eEBZ1l8+Brt2zu6B9cuIqawh98uoe+hEYCrd.aEK5Ox59KPwfUX8fknXgfQZuxDMX.lgHjHfANkke8WWHKOfsroW+0ahmsNdn.1TrHdJ8vlX60yimJxNVD6oHatziqSYgXdJSJPOBCmV70aUbVDT0RmbChAH3F.BXp.OfUdiroeCDtKKOrfhvXaACKBmhfBWWjgHf1.96Mv4ahrtisCeFUdCqPy7poSoJ3RfsBFdj9tfNIt4R3BaCqLq7uXsxpnwFs1XjvRkaW83RskS8UO7uzFVlFVD9NCs.uMaKdaqHNnnSlisYFs.2qrP3VygjUS+ukNkoslpIugNp.hLGACTozryjIAXKUZDYuGH9Cn.Ej+HyWxX2Wm96mVADvt.cfOTJqZZhUOjYd3LpRnkhrbkEQCbmJApI3d0..rZXC0pjwOGw6Cl0bzAeXdBYLq7bkvnffJdn7UpREdbaM+NG0nLlCM027H9MizppqihQFSHHVVdsdpVPTwr7VPeVC6eNwAjYBXsM7FmkefsqANqr7lDqtd8PEAF3k4MfaHks5BrWPyg.Vl5PlU3Z31CuFLmLqxhj2GEWrViL8EvUtoUzAvdZPW2LSfPTBN1GLYBPUzAKyfeFewH1JBUX45o1ePFeHBwNaAMgBE2w14sCghkHNR.pcyDHkq5O+Hhn8BIh1ghnMSD6zI5H2mLZe2hg8STL3WKvZESd.6cXNqMX4rB6evP2dY5OSO1naLyKDpEiuUspUjOToT4CZwWswNM4a2jud0JUUpU5T4CSsndfSsQZlvK96uB2V4SFDWIL4KK1hlIQkZCf.N.DkKUdOdFV32qD.w1+Ct7MeWCJF4KuWoFMjqErTZ8fUB3xZhB4nLf0s0Hn6HobB2jyVQP4eLFPHCVlh+TbMMzYkLRKnfR36yQoEXPK1nTTxnmYa.xCl3+HrpgiFVdeLBVObbcRTJD4eMBYJATcP68pBBdKr1Zz5zrQsSAhjJcXVLFBeEYE4FUjazFFgETgVrPq.tetJUPDoZDZvKCnYtul2f+OF.GnwZqAgw.ql+rFEW1EoxNSvoZqRdYLP4ehBH9DxO2IP0KvgBSlok07zxyakBmBro.lCkQFALKHDXb2ILXHDGDh0MhF3iFyymYeOpOX9g3lR7h4xrBjg1yYHIKeGUSWLsV.ErHEYBMTYiZ0xRUxQntiIrUyOrBhlofUn68tfIsTsZrcd6bXy57s2SNx9uVTp1S9PY92IyWtTCvIPNjl.++V7G0RtRf8lLB2rGtmC0lxifDXTbfqL0GffIvXjB18TPBJWaShv.npDuLDA8gPzoU8y3MmrqAWF28lcktPCvExe6OtRgQJF3y8G55Dmel0o.feoxQilUVJ0SLcJvcE26UxtWE.5.wBxN8ts796yBzMtCXkQPc9+.U6L3ND2P.MI7suKB3VTqlDHx22xETeiADg0FxGo401ldsSYBtPKD.ecLBAfbHYfJ3PzzRwOODlUqKIyDQDuBIM6gVd3kA+UPPlvNx62Q5vUHGkmJHGOzdnGnyyDnyyzkBS7VALXvj7E9QCBtiSAnf5FizpwtyUvDF.a.IUAOGwhPHgACXawL5vmIflu7a7ApebtYr.4nV.zDLS.HedfLkF1HTh8G.TEqFUREe7Rp3mdIM+cIohORIM+LRZj8Jr5+xPkJvq7P4R03kOFyGkQ4P4VPjI9CjOcUFD+R+fhBFtkb7L5XnYnZBAZX.MbvtV1NDZTq.WMZ3ejCg2bFHQrBT6CbQHGPFCIi4+FHIGJWHmREymLnc9Isw+tq8Ko74Ac8hbQJ3lhIUKPoymvnaaF.mlIGExoPcH6v2yj.kCbYkgEHpciUJ4pg5c5R+iQWQcZvRRhrRA0jFPCXtp0b2cq1XWZ9jvxolJcvJ8grW90w9OsxZZ8htFihuDgk1SoAIfdyVhPwjpeCXC0NXQySbfanEDmKA4NyhipUZFdLYNS6xFvhUbdEBZBzkFSUEU0yPfT9EX0DSU+eODtheZ+1NcXNtncwgz2Fpi9drLoe.Ov+HerfKy00hJaQix5YOHSHHQ0wTttS4456DMoN4okK+7DlHnQQapgQ0+7GIHUV3kLFltCIjKwKhe28StX2ceMV58HDZaU0xvq4.h0c8H837qIfiKQZeTAj5Qu21+s92aaogdd1VbF5bI9rjStUahbTXG6Fj+HYQ9EfEetOKfJVN2Vx9FJSvm7B8BKlAD+9sejbXFL7EQ3vKXb3W6yAV.bE7g2f73WjjdammlABaqSepIuOYwBBOO+3VTH9pjray8LJ5+iHX7DWhkjqXd08auQuisU5epngzk8Or59WrY8ZVJVGbltza022sZk0GIYpryE6djzlqs1tUucqc7LT59laOP55t45s2ExZm1UoshtjToGAFY2V86EitFUGu0dU5dPwV2Za6z7hMaeyVmeUi8JN9vNm6z7r2045stUbiJEKulRSmlu85qFs0d5VkJN97ckbZV8f7C2xR93s1X7Fad6UMeScogas35QloN+OCL0yYOUDLdS22zUpjfvM6WQPXTOkQCF0Q5nMzKs+sWr2Z8Uz6WkHocyYEpdq5aNouxYEt9bopaTbX01EEFapb7AmclTIIMypWblbcSkaNqzIOdS8LXjKpdr93Zi251ZiqUbbNCogMmztEblySqMnGOpJ8oYxkHgePOHP3.BjuGiwlnBYjgFg8T8RkrBw8RHcAWhWFdkRfS.S19rfm4GVAJUr9cIm5FrBkiRb3tYh.9G1dbzFWan60aRGU2tGwnauIO+we33swaicva3QpW9wO9wb3.IVJBdd0BFmdgww+7z3.5AJBFVrHq5cHrCBxpTUO1abA2rJvGLqvcA3peJAL2hXY+MIidikm1r9Cu8dUm+omlYM0hk3agspmNGkTeUX5IS7afFynulmLSenJbINOo3qESiOtK7PZ7AcgmzFOKM97svSvVall9XsvyZSOMM8oYQOsM87zzGhE8z1zyoGZGyrjZwRfuvtK+7US7x6xA8UIYO+06TI7mlRIv+uOsR3Oe91IVNxZkdgJ54lnurDii13gVOtJytGMTLnlifsKe21tdjAsLtMV5r3agFM5iWSGHB29rEqln6RDpt8mLQ3OOeQne7WGvI.j9TRYEqed2IBIO++Ekz3h9YerwLhdpEqTq6RzO8GmnOGAI+Tf9i+OWLCneHu66bK9+p6yh2c9mGu67+D5cm+4w6N+OC7ty+73cm+o5cm99JtfcaLmaMi2qi21WLCz+CaGUoBkVLGkZ.ylza9nc6QtwaVVDq5j6rTozARyhma.f7rBwbyBOsZh6Qgn7+Din6tv7zICdbFQfDuSzD1Ud3pVprsgac69vZo5.yLwRtpiHUsvaQFwCeQCmyap3mmrts9PS7gnE8kzFeyz8Gv.vXz2VQ7MRzx0vabr27zktuWr7X2apbK7KV9hB2eURECOsdyGuKMG7h9tOy30+8f+yRJ2oCQyaBXeQxcN4deo2+jCkeKCJ+xjuCbGn26TJP9sz1crc5yuKAbUQcp3874I7eunedBCV3OOglZd.DZ6nZ4Nv1EtjzHbdpwxGcrJDugVwIm0ULpPwaGP7Di5nFzYDJe01vl1XLCZGiS0MhDn3+8aYuR1sHfzn2zUCD13u5v.CFZ5RdGteUL5Dmzc9ncumpiNXWzh4ft7B6U7H9RMd4y0WpwOo62+wGdZ4ECtyQCtjxLeoOv0gZfu6PxV3aSEzChwecxJjNpCM8B5M9Vq51V1C5YaYDyneHwywnaWhSTrOWApjmWruUfuX6CIlDUWRzDT0fLPpNfdh7D0EOvGYShEzd86SxfKOFOf+upRq3+MbjNYviMyOzXPS9PwQ7gQ6Qtj1pT3LwjVEL+NdQ+LMvXUZFmSLiaXlMmzS+q23SQdykWn7lO8MRQcddUvWRCEOuqGApTi43P6fm1yixTHYLv1T0Ay+unVkV8ss85EOkkw1OKFk+Jp3f6ONKj3i+mMkA92kDRFmmm4x7iwo9SCpYu2IcqqBwzug80H0Bp7Qi3+R.fOA2DKgWSHqcNrM0QjXoSa.Wn0G8GTDamvePwfA+IYM5qp4X+cZrmjCty8Uzd.41h9oWkJYcrMe3CpKYxbB43vWYguSSC8o+JP+L+4j+ILm0eByovSXNa7DlSwmvbdySXNaduyAqaqzPO69L+enCEY1WrWhvulP3hA++.TsDHiA
          

          Hise Develop branch
          MacOs 15.3.1, Xcode 16.2
          http://musikboden.se

          ulrikU 1 Reply Last reply Reply Quote 0
          • ulrikU
            ulrik @ulrik
            last edited by

            @ulrik @Christoph-Hart is it possible to fix this, or do I make something wrong when logging the events?

            Hise Develop branch
            MacOs 15.3.1, Xcode 16.2
            http://musikboden.se

            MikeBM 1 Reply Last reply Reply Quote 0
            • MikeBM
              MikeB @ulrik
              last edited by

              Is there a solution here - does anyone have an idea?

              "One hour of trial and error can save 10 minutes of reading the manual."
              "It's easier to hit the developer with feature requests than to spend 10 minutes reading the manual. :-)))"
              HISE Develop - Mac Pro 5.1, OS X 10.14.6, Projucer 6.02, Xcode 10.3

              ulrikU 1 Reply Last reply Reply Quote 0
              • ulrikU
                ulrik @MikeB
                last edited by

                @Christoph-Hart
                Related to this issue of not being able to grab notes by their midi channel in the NoteOn Cb, I tried a different approach using no arp or midi players at all. Instead I've built 4 arpeggiators manually and now to my question:

                I use the TransportHandler and made the "NoteOn callback inside the GridChange function set to 18, 1/96 (1/64T)

                const TH = Engine.createTransportHandler();
                TH.setEnableGrid(true, 18);
                TH.setSyncMode(TH.PreferExternal);
                
                if (MPsActivate[0].getValue())
                	{
                		local nv = NVLookUpNum[MPsSpeed[0].getValue()-1];
                		
                		if (gridcount % (nv*96) == 0)
                		{
                			slider1 == NumSliders.getValue()-1 ? slider1 = 0 : slider1++;
                			
                			//for (sp in S)
                			local nn = MPSPs[0][0].getSliderValueAt(slider1);
                			local v = MPSPs[0][1].getSliderValueAt(slider1);
                			local l = MPSPs[0][2].getSliderValueAt(slider1);
                			
                			local len = Engine.getSamplesForQuarterBeats(nv*l*4);
                			
                			for (n in PKs)
                			{
                				local ev = Synth.addNoteOn(1, Math.range(nn + n, 0, 126), v, 0);
                				Synth.noteOffDelayedByEventId(ev, len);
                				
                			}
                		}
                	}
                

                I have not tested this carefully yet.

                Is there a drawback using this approach?
                It feels like it will not be as accurate as using the built in NoteOn cb

                Hise Develop branch
                MacOs 15.3.1, Xcode 16.2
                http://musikboden.se

                1 Reply Last reply Reply Quote 0
                • First post
                  Last post

                43

                Online

                1.7k

                Users

                11.7k

                Topics

                102.3k

                Posts