why does short decay make the sound quieter...
-
I've noticed a strance behavior in my faust synth design
a very short decay time seems to produce a very quiet blip, not just a short one of equal loudness than one with a longer decay. this only happens in hise, not in faust IDE
here's a snippet
HiseSnippet 2294.3oc6Z07aaibEmTxzNVqSxFfEX6gBTB2K1FJJjx5KuoAV1RVIFM1wqUhwBDrvcD4HoolhjkbjsUWTf.Tfhdqm2KEE8uh1SsnGKPO0a8TP+Kv8POm9lYHkHkjUrUbbhCpsAr36MuY9Mu4807nvmRw1lXyC8sIttXpjjbx87bLv99NdRxoddOWrj7BJ06YSaWoMhXKscUI46p7BaeJpgE9.GhAVZydtHeerojrbxGyFj77yHw+4r02DYgrgwzmjjDWnmR5PnCntW4eJwxpFxD+bRmHiNW4sMbrq3X4zE.TREMIWjwQnV3cQrgkPQ5IH+1RxqnXpmSuYICTgR54xZXjsTwrqUz.iZ1DWPOewbkZlqIxPKqj7raYRnNd0oHJ1WRdlMcL6UusyI1hE3.hOA1ZrGzkpCqrfbMGKS1VjQUpRahkYeMkOn2Thn2RJzaegxNDSRe5CzeeNmg5.Ihp.kSDGdIiAO8nvSKB7FCjji.oYDP5dJ0M7HtzAbX34yT11lh8.0S7yRwXkRbeYkG7.0MAEeKOmt1lp+3Z0z3+jl8wr55Extp3iE0qlKu58U2rKk5XyHUIegRUpv4VpVgBUJv+3lEVKakroRUwAVYaZlNniv07fG5ijkJ.S+pZZK+vTsrbZfrTscn3sM8Uej5K+1GlpYWaCJAVCG6cAFOydokS8colO0uJk5vrZ1br7XqsmikE1arrYFhdSRvkr61oA1Ks5wHqt39CDT1wOAUN+SvnFXFBUQjA5XusMg9LWr84Y1IEn+fO8hsqhnH1wd.MXbtXOJgAA4p3iAmNgQv7JUw9GQcb4isiqiMaFj+LJm6sCMQP1XKIhIy+evQuzoQ8j6E8gFsBcSWPIW1hkzWSSqjlDgh6DkQIsUyWJ2p4ivHaHmh4WMWwhRmPLos6O0u52TtMlzp8fnEuta4FNdlXu5jeYrHKBp6iLIc8iRWZTOAvGzwrqEhF2wjE9JfAbVGyafYYZ6Sn8hFd6Jya8hBw6orGgZzd7XLwXvHXQ79.iAw3tsxVP.VC5..NiRsu4ZHflhX8SorgMxpmONLRV3i5wvvlcATNj4xes7ddfWA9j.uh.x2prbxKLf0mr9ZemtThcqcPTOB33nra2N0A6cCLntrA2KVvA4DL2XwyZrmYfnNjVl+vafeBXpydVNfodHynmI2MV95GCNrtbsxBJGT4Y5pBBmWxZ4e9+9hlr18BmrdKaVUB01I5LVA44QvdaCEdDIXxY+k9F6iv4E1DeGaGNT1nCDFhF0ELfaULsqcHX9Y+t+1+IjQcWOLxLpDLzWGCP0jOk9wbnSNopCzmxpCl6itpCtADRLl+dfs8bJa7jp02OnLTtY8V1GisfTcwP1NvAuaaGahQTSu8wfiXqVPvhH3crahMnTHmWktdGGyanJ1.0aDphAOJkmhAjEk7S.qjQltADdY45cg5piV.MCyVXj+f06u+GKukgCbffmRk9jiYEqP1IYXbaEwlTkGC3RaULyEypXx9UWTi36DhUwIxG2fcAEtYwMA85cUBLXuQnXuiRfuzMAU6DqyK4mz04cYbTX47UAduspf+.ToNTFFuxiOfv6VgGd0IVrqVxJKjisY4oNOuZAeU00d8UesfueprZlOIqrJw++xlenurYhQ0Q2QYOGqdh1i.qKC.eImjnRSUAG0ZeS1w0FM4ejx3ZhTj9FobUcuyAcEZWL8DGui3USG7YnHZFxmWAVD5ypWQZCKKmSXMBhDbHCXlSavVicbKFQ3UWCuGl39qOA4+bDwhMLnh.W3BpOylGygE.QN4AXOe9DOmhVF3WP6tKu.1YqgLfcbu8PrF9bOEVOvfyVrWFi9mwC.ZTkpn+uC3wluvnMh6PC3sCuwVITDs0NraXhKVvdBrbSHBUus+ALtFHKoCXcyisS3yoPyI.qXnN9FPDOlihzHn2CmIB6QwaLouLPlwx0BeZXO9pR7csP8D80veDJr8k3VzhtDrUmFXSHLJW79cN.4AfhJje19OAmR6PrCzBCbr2Ac5Pz97x0oX23MU4r0qeD9DgdI1kr3Ic32ZYnY4r0qhah5ZQGYEklLjxUdDH8a+mCCo+v2+8+4QgT4ecm+w5h9EUyC+K5B1o8FBWu5nxiEW.82BtNa8QUUZWRU0BbbotOye7hpvNacoK+YH.hK4Y3igfSW6PRR57gzbJ60lcA4Ql5ozt5p.SyxysOMpIlu9lNNG0AwiZOUs0W5cH0k9MfTWyprAqGPejm2J.kilDHfw0UFq4T.aNeZ7jUKHRVI3LJDCk4RgwDCgw4UpXAy61lg.LEOaMeyKMzXuKq23QbBBjPrluyYp9ACG9806zXuIF9UzuH9UZdeFWIJv9RlMlllt3MqpkqXt0JlKudrnLJvXxE7lN3cIJNB+uu4MO3q+We23By75u9O86uRhF+VTc2R4o3VP4MWapsKBntcXmeduefdYUW2IrCZhFnccmCaxo5aMlT8S.R0OgcYwmi7Zgo9C409tmS653co8oxZzAY34bngHMMKl4s3Tf.11AWaZG1yp5RGO7oXGhI4PCi3S0HBlcZEb0oUvbSqf4mVAKLsBVbZErzaWPVCr1nK0oinhGvOeusDWpSV7tV4IwkvA22ST+FymqOEa7o0fJb3UIzjvpIKA6eBj7Eh79OHLOcFSe2vuXJRI9gIUHcbc7nKsnO0jOxLVjFKx9J5.gJTejZC9W6mkVj8HibJj38tL+7y+H019VDSr2RKNH45K8o8rve0Q1NM91ESqA+VHMKKnNHqI+sfDWx947FRvLZqFSV+fWKAS3iCENZj1QWX89B6E7VBhIbjDHSBzvTWE6RaGW3PpwkTO1pZwSaJ1u8ETjKcRfskXaFUHFoIIRJHrrqppPJrcFjou2RZoUC22qnpkQOeZUM9e5p2WkcbxNQ5K3.4DGvoUEmVbQAYf0KTHOe1KmkuVZYXe0v3SBafYyCS4vbMGvVCfJ6U6ZPn83qo9JKoe+Pc4JKAOv1pKu7xOTMUJbvqANJ5NrAA4GGhoUCrM5ueSyVYfKGI.0f+KNO5uMR4JtkBe5Obk9ql5O4qTOL8gOTUR5+Ic2YyJ
if you lower the decay ever so slightly you notice it getting quieter not just shorter....
It can't be the waveform as it starts with -1 so something inside HISE is stealing the transient. can it have to do with buffer size?
this also happens with no module tree envelope but a silent killer node etc. so the yellow hise envelope doesn't seem to be the problem. is there maybe some smoothing happening along the way? -
@Morphoice bump
-
@Morphoice bump
-
RMS.
Is it only in your current VCO design?
-
@aaronventure I don't know, I haven't designed other VCO's as I don't need those. the snipped provided is simple enough, it's a stock oscillator and a faust envelope. can't make it much simpler than that
-
@Morphoice happens here too, no idea why